Oct 11, 2024 Leave a message

Heat Resistant Cast Steel: Alloy Types, Creep Life and Welding

What Heat Resistant Cast Steel Is Asked to Do

Heat resistant cast steel is specified where a component must carry load at a temperature high enough that ordinary carbon and low alloy steels would oxidise, sag or fail by creep. In furnace service the requirement is rarely a single number. A reformer tube or a radiant burner component is simultaneously exposed to 900 to 1150 degrees Celsius, to internal pressure, to thermal cycling on every shutdown, to a carburising or oxidising gas, and to its own weight plus the weight of the catalyst or the charge. The casting must hold its shape for the design life, which in petrochemical plants is normally written as 100 000 hours of operation, and in practice is expected to reach 6 to 10 years of continuous duty.

The reason castings dominate this field is metallurgical rather than commercial. At the same chemical composition, a cast structure with its coarse grains and interlocking dendritic network has markedly higher creep and stress rupture strength than the wrought product, because grain boundaries are the fast diffusion paths for creep damage and the cast structure simply has fewer of them per unit volume. That advantage is decisive in the 900 to 1150 degree window. Casting also solves the forming problem: the 25 percent chromium, 35 percent nickel alloys used for cracking tubes are close to unforgeable, so shapes are produced by static casting or by centrifugal casting rather than by rolling or extrusion.

The Standard Framework Buyers Should Name

Heat resistant castings are covered by a layered set of standards, and a purchase specification is only complete when the correct one is named. ASTM A297 / A297M covers iron-chromium and nickel-chromium heat resistant castings for general application and supplies the familiar letter designations HF, HH, HK, HL, HN and HP. ASTM A447 covers similar nickel-chromium castings for higher temperature use, and ASTM A560 extends the family for particular high temperature duties. Where the part is a pressure containing tube, ASTM A608 covers centrifugally cast iron-chromium-nickel high alloy tubing for pressure service at high temperature, and ASTM A351 / A351M covers austenitic steel castings for pressure containing parts at moderate elevated temperature with the CF and CK designations. For creep rated Cr-Mo castings at more modest temperatures, ASTM A217 covers grades such as WC6, WC9 and C12 used for valve bodies and fittings.

Outside the ASTM system, EN 10295 covers heat resistant steel castings, ISO 11973 covers the same class of material, JIS G5122 covers heat resistant cast steel in the Japanese system, and GB/T 8492 covers heat resistant steel castings in the Chinese system. The grade letters are not interchangeable across systems: an HK type in one table and an HK type in another may differ by a few tenths of a percent of carbon and by a percent or two of nickel, which is enough to change the creep life at the top of the temperature range. Always quote the standard number and edition, and require the certificate to quote them as well.

Composition Ranges and What Each Element Buys

Chromium provides the protective oxide scale and is the primary determinant of oxidation resistance. Below roughly 18 percent the scale becomes unstable above about 900 degrees Celsius in air; at 25 percent chromium the alloy tolerates continuous exposure in the 1050 to 1100 degree range, and 28 to 32 percent chromium grades extend that further in sulphur bearing or ash bearing atmospheres. Nickel stabilises the austenite so that the alloy does not transform to martensite on cooling, and it improves high temperature ductility and carburisation resistance, at a substantial cost penalty. Carbon in these alloys is not a contaminant: it forms primary and secondary carbides that carry the creep strength, which is why heat resistant castings run at carbon levels that would be unacceptable in a weldable wrought steel.

Strengthening additions come next. Niobium forms a stable MC carbide that resists coarsening and delays the creep damage that begins with the transformation of chromium carbides toward sigma phase. Tungsten and molybdenum go into solid solution and into complex carbides, raising rupture strength at the top of the range. Cobalt raises the solution temperature of the matrix and is used in the most highly rated cracking tube alloys. Silicon improves oxidation resistance but raises the brittle to ductile transition and promotes sigma formation if it is pushed too far, so it is usually held below about 2 percent.

Type Cr, % nom. Ni, % nom. C, % nom. Typical service limit Typical parts
HF 19 - 23 8 - 12 0.20 - 0.40 About 900 C Furnace parts, hearth supports
HH 24 - 28 11 - 14 0.20 - 0.50 About 980 C Radiant tubes, retorts, grates
HK 23 - 27 19 - 22 0.35 - 0.45 About 1050 - 1100 C Reformer and cracking tubes
HL 28 - 32 18 - 22 0.20 - 0.30 About 1050 C Sulphur bearing furnace atmospheres
HN 19 - 23 23 - 27 0.20 - 0.35 About 1050 C Tube supports, load carrying hangers
HP 24 - 28 33 - 37 0.35 - 0.75 About 1100 - 1150 C Ethylene cracking tubes, outlet headers

The figures are nominal type compositions from the heat resistant casting tables and are given to show the pattern, not to replace the standard. Two practical points follow. First, the difference between an HK type and an HP type is not a refinement, it is a different alloy family with a different cost per kilogram and a different welding procedure; a substitution request during a turnaround must be treated as an engineering change. Second, the modified versions that carry an added suffix for niobium, tungsten or cobalt are what the cracking and reforming industry actually uses, and their rupture strength at 1100 degrees Celsius can be more than double that of the plain type, so the suffix matters more than the base designation.

Centrifugal Casting: Why Furnace Tubes Are Made This Way

Furnace tubes for steam reforming and ethylene cracking are produced by centrifugal casting, either in the horizontal mode for long straight lengths or in the vertical mode for shorter, thicker sections. Molten metal is poured into a rotating metal mould; centrifugal force drives the denser liquid against the mould wall while inclusions, gas and less dense phases migrate to the inner surface, which is then machined away. The result is a sound, pore free wall with a fine outer skin and a controlled inner bore, and it is the only practical way to make a 25 percent chromium, 35 percent nickel tube ten metres long with a wall thick enough to carry pressure at 1100 degrees Celsius.

Quality control of a centrifugally cast tube concentrates on wall thickness uniformity and ovality, since a thin patch becomes the hot spot that determines the tube life, and on the inner bore quality after machining, since internal oxide scale and casting skin act as stress raisers. Tubes are normally supplied machined on the outside for weld preparation and either machined or as-cast on the bore depending on the design. Ultrasonic testing for internal shrinkage and radiography of the weld end regions are standard; dye penetrant examination of machined surfaces catches the surface connected defects that matter most.

For a purchaser, the deliverable that ties all this together is a dimensional and metallurgical report per heat: chemistry from a sample representing the cast, the centrifugal casting parameters, wall thickness measurements at defined stations, results of the NDT, and where specified, a stress rupture test on a specimen cut from a prolongation. Stress rupture results are the only test that directly predicts life at temperature, and they take weeks to obtain, which is why they are specified for critical tubes and skipped for general furnace hardware.

Butt Welding, Tube to Header Joints and Dissimilar Connections

Heat resistant cast tubes are joined by welding in the field and in the fabrication shop, and the joint is the part of the system that fails first. The alloys are austenitic, so they have high thermal expansion, low thermal conductivity and a strong tendency to hot crack if the weld metal ferrite content and the heat input are not controlled. Matching filler metal is normally used for cast to cast joints, with a controlled ferrite level to resist solidification cracking, a low interpass temperature, and a narrow weave.

Cast to wrought joints are more demanding. A centrifugally cast HP type tube welded to a wrought ASTM A335 P22 or P91 header involves a large difference in creep strength and in thermal expansion, and the joint is usually made through a transition piece with an intermediate composition, or with a nickel based filler that accommodates the mismatch. Preheating is not normally required for the austenitic cast side, but the ferritic side of the joint must follow its own procedure, and any post weld heat treatment applied for the ferritic component must not be allowed to degrade the cast austenitic part, which is why the weld is often made with the ferritic side heat treated before the final joint.

Ageing is a design consideration in welded assemblies. Service exposure precipitates secondary carbides, and in high chromium alloys it also forms sigma phase, both of which raise hardness and reduce ductility. A cast HK or HP component that has seen 50 000 hours at temperature can have very low room temperature ductility, and cutting or welding it during a turnaround carries a real risk of cracking. Retubing procedures therefore specify cutting methods, preheat, and inspection, and often require a weld qualification on an aged sample rather than on new material.

Failure Modes and What They Tell the Operator

Heat resistant cast components fail in a small number of recognisable ways, and the appearance of the failure usually identifies the cause. Creep rupture shows as diametral expansion, ovality, or a longitudinal split with a thick lipped edge and little macroscopic deformation elsewhere. Thermal fatigue shows as a network of fine transverse cracks that begin at the inner or outer surface and grow with each cycle; it is the classic failure of a tube that is repeatedly quenched or that has a temperature gradient across the wall.

Carburisation shows as a hardened, carbide rich layer that grows inward from the process side, changing the local composition so that the alloy no longer matches its specification, and eventually causing a low ductility fracture. Oxidation, by contrast, shows as a uniform loss of wall from the outer surface, which is a life limit defined by remaining thickness rather than by a crack. Sigma phase embrittlement does not produce a visible defect until a crack appears, and is detected by metallographic replication or by hardness survey rather than by any external inspection.

The most expensive failures are the ones that follow a well intentioned repair. A weld made without removing the aged, embrittled layer, a thermal cut left unground, or a local hot spot created by a misaligned tube support will all initiate cracking within a few hundred hours. Recorded tube metal temperatures, together with the burn pattern of the flame and the fuel gas composition, are the data needed to interpret a failure, and a metallurgical report that describes the failure mode without those service records is of limited use.

Selection Rules That Hold Up in Practice

Choose the alloy from the temperature and the atmosphere, then check the mechanical duty. For oxidising service in air up to about 900 degrees Celsius, an HF or HH type casting is adequate and economical. Between 900 and 1050 degrees, an HK or HL type is the normal choice, with HL favoured where sulphur or fuel ash is present. Above 1050 degrees, the 25 percent chromium, 35 percent nickel family with niobium, and where necessary tungsten or cobalt, becomes the standard, and the designer should be prepared to accept both a higher price and a more demanding fabrication procedure.

Then check the load path. A casting that carries its own weight plus a catalyst load plus the moment imposed by a connected piping system is not a simple pressure vessel; the bending stress at the support or at the header connection is often what limits life, and it should be evaluated against the rupture strength at the metal temperature, not against the room temperature yield strength. Wall thickness for pressure is calculated from the high temperature allowable stress by a recognised procedure such as the one in API 530 for fired heater tubes, and the result should be checked against a minimum thickness for oxidation allowance and for handling during installation.

Finally, define the acceptance documentation. At a minimum the purchase should require a certified chemical analysis per heat, a heat treatment record where a heat treatment is specified, dimensional and wall thickness reports, NDT reports to a named method and acceptance level, and a positive material identification check by X-ray fluorescence on delivery, since the difference between a 25Cr/20Ni and a 25Cr/35Ni casting is not visible to the eye and cannot be detected by a magnet.

FAQ

Q: Why is a cast heat resistant tube stronger than a rolled tube of the same composition?
Creep damage accumulates along grain boundaries, and the coarse cast grain structure provides far fewer boundaries per unit volume than a wrought structure with its fine recrystallised grains. At 900 to 1150 degrees Celsius this gives cast HK and HP type material a clear rupture strength advantage over the wrought equivalent.

Q: What is the difference between an HK type and an HP type casting?
HK types sit at roughly 25 percent chromium and 20 percent nickel and are used to about 1050 to 1100 degrees Celsius. HP types raise nickel to roughly 35 percent with higher carbon and are used to about 1100 to 1150 degrees Celsius, typically with niobium, tungsten or cobalt additions for creep strength. They are different alloy families, not grades of the same material.

Q: Why do these castings need a stress rupture test rather than only a tensile test?
Tensile properties at room temperature say almost nothing about performance at 1000 degrees Celsius, where failure is time dependent. A stress rupture test at the design temperature and stress predicts the life that matters, which is why it is specified for reformer and cracking tubes and omitted only for non critical furnace hardware.

Q: Can an aged heat resistant casting be welded during a turnaround?
It can, but the aged material has low room temperature ductility from secondary carbide and sigma precipitation, so welding requires a qualified procedure on aged material, controlled heat input, and grinding of any thermally cut surface. Many operators specify pre qualified repair procedures and inspect every repair weld by dye penetrant.

Q: How is a heat resistant casting identified on site?
By positive material identification, normally X-ray fluorescence, checked against the heat number and the mill certificate. Visual inspection and a magnet are useless here because all these alloys are austenitic and non-magnetic, and the colour difference between 20 percent nickel and 35 percent nickel is not detectable.

Q: What limits the life of a centrifugal cast furnace tube in normal service?
In clean, correctly fired service the limit is creep, expressed as diameter growth or bulging beyond an agreed criterion. In practice the life is usually shortened by overtemperature from a flame impingement or a blocked burner, by carburisation from the process gas, or by thermal fatigue from repeated cycling.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry