What "Inspection and Supply" Means in a Seamless Tube Contract
In a seamless tube purchase there are two distinct obligations, and confusing them is the root of most delivery disputes. The supply basis defines which properties the mill guarantees and therefore which tests it must perform on every lot. The inspection regime defines how those guarantees are verified, at what frequency, by which method, and with what acceptance criteria. A mill certificate that reports tensile results proves nothing about wall thickness eccentricity along the length, and a dimensional report proves nothing about internal soundness. The purchase order has to carry both.
For seamless tube the supply basis in Chinese practice is normally one of three options: supply according to chemical composition and mechanical properties, supply according to mechanical properties only, or supply according to a specified hydraulic test. Each shifts a different part of the risk to the mill, and the buyer who does not state one receives whichever basis the mill applies by default, which is usually the least onerous.
Dimensional Inspection: Wall Thickness
Wall thickness is the single most consequential dimension. It sets the pressure rating, the joint strength after threading, and the machining allowance. Because a seamless tube is produced by piercing and rolling, wall thickness varies both around the circumference and along the length, and the acceptance decision must be made on the minimum value rather than the average.
Hand measurement uses an outside micrometer with spherical anvels or a dedicated tube micrometer, taken at a defined number of points. A practical and widely used protocol is a minimum of eight measurement points at each end of the tube, distributed around the circumference, with all readings recorded against the tube identification. The reason for measuring at both ends is that the ends carry the upset, the threading and the weld preparation, and they are also where eccentricity is often worst.
Ultrasonic thickness gauging is used for volume checking and for full-length scanning. A contact probe with couplant gives a spot reading; a rotating or array system gives a continuous wall profile and can be set to alarm on the minimum. Ultrasonic gauging does not replace micrometer measurement at the reference points in a dispute, because sound velocity depends on the steel grade and on the calibration block used, but it is far faster for screening and for detecting longitudinal wall thinning that point measurement would miss.
The acceptance rule should be written as a minimum wall, not as a nominal wall with a percentage, because percentage tolerances compound with size. If the design calculation gives a required minimum of 7.10 mm and the applicable standard permits minus 10 percent, the ordered nominal wall must be 7.89 mm or greater, rounded to the next available mill size. Reversing that arithmetic after delivery is not possible.
Dimensional Inspection: Diameter, Ovality, Length and Straightness
Outside diameter is measured with a caliper for small sizes and with a circumferential tape or a laser gauge for larger sizes, taking the maximum and minimum reading on the same cross section. Ovality, the difference between those two readings divided by the nominal diameter, matters most when the tube will be threaded, coupled, rolled or bent. For well casing and line pipe that will be assembled with mechanical couplings, an ovality limit of one percent of nominal diameter is a common requirement, tighter than the general standard default.
Inside diameter and bore condition become acceptance criteria for cylinder, sleeve and precision applications. Where the bore is not machined, a bore gauge or an internal micrometer at defined positions verifies the tolerance; where it is honed, roundness and surface roughness measured to a defined cutoff length are added. Wall eccentricity, expressed as the ratio of the difference between maximum and minimum wall to the nominal wall, is the parameter that links the outside and inside geometry, and it should be stated explicitly for any tube that will be machined after receipt.
Length is verified with a steel tape or by the mill's automatic measuring system, and the acceptance criterion depends on whether random or fixed length was ordered. For fixed length, the tolerance should be stated both as a plus and a minus value, because mills cut to a length while the tube is moving and a one-sided tolerance is difficult to hold. Automatic length measurement linked to the cut-off saw is standard on modern lines and is more consistent than manual measurement for high volume.
Straightness is measured against a one metre steel straightedge with a feeler gauge to obtain the local deviation per metre, and separately over the full length with a taut wire or a laser reference. Both numbers must be specified, because a tube can satisfy a per-metre limit while bowing significantly over twelve metres. A common requirement for casing and for tubes that will be machined in a lathe between centres is 1.0 to 1.5 mm per metre local deviation and no more than 0.2 percent of length overall. For tubes that will be cold bent, straightness also affects the bend, since the bend plane follows the original curvature.
End preparation is inspected with a square, a bevel protractor and a root face gauge. The bevel angle, typically 30 degrees plus 0 minus 2.5 degrees for a standard V preparation, the root face of 1.6 mm plus or minus 0.8 mm, and the land and any internal trim must match the welding procedure qualification. A bevel that is out of tolerance forces a site repair, which is far more expensive than rejecting the tube at the mill.
Surface Quality: Visual Examination and Its Limits
Visual inspection of the tube surface is a controlled process, not a glance at the bundle. It requires defined illumination, a defined viewing distance, a clean and dry surface, and a procedure that states what constitutes a reportable imperfection. In practice the tube is rotated under light so that the full circumference passes the inspector's field of view, and both the outside surface and, where accessible, the bore are examined.
The imperfections that matter on seamless tube are longitudinal and transverse seams and laps, rolled-in scale, scabs, pits, die marks on cold drawn product, straightening marks, and mechanical damage from handling. The acceptance rule in the general standards is expressed in terms of depth relative to wall thickness: an imperfection is acceptable only if its depth does not reduce the wall below the minimum permitted thickness, and seams, laps and cracks are not acceptable regardless of depth because they act as stress raisers. Visual inspection cannot establish depth, so any indication at the limit of visibility must be evaluated by magnetic particle, liquid penetrant or ultrasonic means before a decision is made.
Marking readability is part of the same inspection. Grade, size, heat number and standard reference must be legible on each tube or bundle, and where the tube is coated or galvanised the marking must be reproduced on a durable tag. A delivery whose heat number cannot be read has lost traceability even if the steel is correct.
Non-Destructive Testing: Choosing the Right Method
Non-destructive testing is selected by the defect type being sought and by the metallurgy of the steel, not by convenience. For carbon and low alloy seamless tube the primary concern is longitudinal and transverse discontinuity in the wall, and ultrasonic testing to ASTM E213 or the ISO 10893 series is the standard method. A full body scan with probes arranged for both longitudinal and transverse detection is the normal configuration for pressure and boiler tube, and the acceptance criteria are defined by reference notch dimensions rather than by an open-ended description.
Eddy current testing is used for surface and near-surface discontinuity and for sorting. It is fast and well suited to small diameter tube and to tube that will be subsequently bent or machined. For austenitic stainless steel, conventional ultrasonic testing suffers from high attenuation and from the anisotropic grain structure of the cast or heavily worked material, so eddy current testing to ASTM E309, which is written specifically for austenitic and other austenitic-ferritic materials, is the appropriate route, sometimes supplemented by ultrasonic testing with a low frequency dual element technique.
Magnetic particle testing to ASTM E709 is applied to ferromagnetic tube for surface and slightly subsurface discontinuity, most often at cut ends, at weld preparations and on tubes that have been straightened or locally worked. Liquid penetrant testing to ASTM E165 is the alternative for austenitic and other non-ferromagnetic grades, and it detects only surface-connected indications, so the surface must be clean and free of scale or paint before testing.
Radiographic testing to ASTM E94 and ASTM E142 is used where the through-wall condition must be visualised, typically on heavy wall tube, on the end regions where the piercing operation leaves the highest risk of internal defect, and where a contract requires a permanent image record. Radiography is slow and requires access to both sides, so it is normally applied to a defined sample or to the tube ends rather than to the full length. Magnetic flux leakage and electromagnetic acoustic methods are used on some lines for fast full body screening, but their acceptance criteria must be correlated with a proven reference standard before they can be used as the release test.
Hydrostatic and Alternative Pressure Testing
The hydrostatic test verifies that the tube contains pressure without leakage or permanent deformation. Test pressure is calculated from the outside diameter, the specified wall thickness, the allowable stress at test temperature and a test stress factor defined in the governing standard, using the thin-wall formula. Hold time is typically not less than five seconds for standard tube, longer where the specification or a third-party witness requires it, and the pressure is measured with a calibrated gauge whose range places the test pressure in the middle third of the scale.
Two practical points decide whether the test is meaningful. The first is the wall thickness used in the calculation: using nominal wall rather than the minimum permitted wall overstates the real margin, and some specifications require the calculation to be based on minimum wall. The second is the treatment of the ends. Ends that are not sealed and restrained will leak or deform, and the sealing method must not mark or ovalise the tube end, since that would create a defect during the test itself.
Where the parties agree, a non-destructive electric test may replace the hydrostatic test. This substitution is common for small diameter tube and for stainless grades, and it is legitimate only when the electric test method and acceptance criteria are written into the order. An electric test detects discontinuity; it does not prove pressure containment, so the substitution is a change in the evidence provided and should be a conscious decision rather than an unremarked mill default.
The Three Supply Bases and What Each One Shifts
Supply by chemical composition and mechanical properties is the most complete basis. The mill guarantees that the heat chemistry falls within the specified ranges and that the product meets the tensile, yield and elongation requirements. It is appropriate where weldability, heat treatment response or corrosion resistance depends on chemistry, which covers alloy boiler tube, stainless tube and any tube that will be welded under a qualified procedure.
Supply by mechanical properties only allows the mill to adjust chemistry within its own practice as long as the mechanical results comply. It is acceptable for general structural and machining tube where the part is designed on strength alone and no welding or corrosion duty is involved. The buyer who needs to know carbon equivalent for a welding procedure must not accept this basis, because chemistry is not guaranteed under it.
Supply by hydraulic test is the narrowest basis. The tube is released against a pressure test, and the mechanical and chemical guarantees are correspondingly limited. It suits low duty fluid service where the only requirement is containment. It is not a basis for boiler, alloy or sour service, and it should never be accepted for a tube that will be threaded and used in a pressure system without an additional material certificate.
Whichever basis applies, the order should also state the inspection and test plan, the witness points, the certificate type to EN 10204, and whether a third-party inspection body is involved. Classification society work adds survey and stamping requirements on top of the material standard, and those requirements have lead time implications that need to be built into the schedule.
Inspection Matrix: Item, Method, Reference and Frequency
| Inspection item | Method | Typical reference | Frequency / sample |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wall thickness at ends | Micrometer, 8 points per end | Product standard tolerance | Every tube or agreed sample |
| Full length wall profile | Ultrasonic thickness scan | ISO 10893 series | Per lot or continuous |
| Outside diameter and ovality | Caliper, tape, laser gauge | Product standard, 1 percent ovality | Both ends of each tube |
| Length | Steel tape, automatic gauge | Fixed or random length clause | Every tube |
| Straightness | 1 m straightedge with feeler gauge, taut wire | 1.0 to 1.5 mm per metre | Every tube |
| Bevel and root face | Square, protractor, gauge | Welding procedure requirement | Both ends of beveled tube |
| Surface condition | Visual under defined illumination | Product standard defect limits | 100 percent |
| Body discontinuity | Ultrasonic to ASTM E213 | Reference notch criteria | Per order or 100 percent |
| Austenitic surface and body | Eddy current to ASTM E309 | Reference notch criteria | Per order or 100 percent |
| Surface crack indication | Magnetic particle ASTM E709, penetrant ASTM E165 | No linear indication | Repair verification, ends |
| Pressure containment | Hydrostatic test or agreed electric test | Thin-wall formula, 5 s hold | Every tube or per agreed plan |
| Tensile and yield | Tensile test per product standard | Grade minima | One per test unit of heat |
| Chemistry | Spectrometric analysis of product | Grade limits, CE limit | Per heat |
| Identity of alloy grades | Positive material identification | Grade confirmation | 100 percent at goods receipt |
Documentation, Release and Common Inspection Gaps
Release documentation should be checked for internal consistency before the material leaves the mill, because contradictions found after shipment are expensive. The heat number on each tube must appear on the certificate; the certificate must cover every test in the order; the grade and size must match the packing list; and any deviation accepted during production must be recorded as a concession rather than left implicit.
The most common inspection gap is a dimensional report that records average wall rather than minimum wall. The second is a non-destructive test report that states the method but not the acceptance level or reference notch, which makes the result unverifiable. The third is a hydrostatic test record without the gauge calibration certificate, which cannot be used as evidence. The fourth is a certificate for a heat that was subsequently re-tested after a failed result, with only the passing result reported. Each of these is closed by writing the reporting requirements into the order, not by inspecting harder at the end.
Handling and protection belong to the same chapter as inspection, because damage after the release test invalidates it. Thread protectors on both ends, wooden or plastic separators between bundles, lifting with nylon slings rather than chains, and covered storage for stainless and coated tube are all part of delivering what the certificate claims.
FAQ
Q: How many wall thickness readings should be taken per tube end?
A practical minimum is eight readings distributed around the circumference at each end, with the minimum value recorded. For pressure and boiler tube the specification often requires the readings to be logged individually against the tube number so that the minimum wall used in the design calculation can be shown to be present at the critical location.
Q: Can a non-destructive electric test replace the hydrostatic test?
Only where the order explicitly permits it and defines the method and acceptance criteria. The two tests provide different evidence: hydrostatic testing demonstrates containment under a defined pressure, while an electric test detects discontinuity in the wall. Substituting one for the other changes what the buyer knows about the tube, so it must be a written decision rather than a mill default.
Q: Which NDT method is suitable for 316L heat exchanger tube?
Eddy current testing to ASTM E309, which is written for austenitic materials where conventional ultrasonic examination is impaired by grain structure and attenuation. Ultrasonic testing with a suitably selected technique can be added for wall thickness profiling, but the primary body examination for austenitic tube is eddy current.
Q: What does "supply according to mechanical properties" exclude?
It excludes a guarantee of chemical composition, so the buyer receives no assurance of carbon equivalent, residual element levels, or suitability for a specific welding procedure or corrosive environment. Where weldability or corrosion resistance is a design requirement, the order must specify supply according to chemical composition and mechanical properties.
Q: Why is straightness specified both per metre and over the full length?
Because the two limits control different problems. Local deviation per metre governs whether the tube can be gripped, machined or rolled in a straight line, while total deviation over the full length governs whether it can be assembled into a long string or inserted into a borehole. A tube can satisfy one criterion and fail the other, so both must be stated.
Q: What should be checked on a mill certificate before accepting a delivery?
Confirm that the heat number matches the marking on the tubes, that the grade and size match the order, that every required test is reported with a result and not merely a method, that the certificate type matches the contractual requirement, and that any retest or concession is disclosed. For alloy grades, add a positive material identification check on the physical tubes, because the certificate alone cannot detect a mixed lot.





