What Liquid Nitriding Means in Production
Liquid nitriding, more precisely called liquid nitrocarburising or salt-bath nitrocarburising, is a thermo-chemical treatment carried out in a molten salt bath held between about 560 C and 600 C. The work piece absorbs both nitrogen and a small amount of carbon, and the result is a thin compound zone of typically 8 um to 25 um backed by a shallow diffusion zone. The process is a ferritic treatment: it is done below the transformation temperature of the steel, so there is no austenitising, no quench from above the critical range and no martensitic hardening of the core. The treated part keeps its dimensions and its core properties, and the surface gains wear resistance, running-in behaviour and, with a post-oxidation step, useful short-term corrosion resistance.
This is why the process is common on thin-walled tube, on long slender shafts and on parts with finished bores that cannot be ground afterwards. A hydraulic cylinder tube that has already been honed to size can be nitrocarburised and returned to service without a finishing operation, because dimensional change on the treated diameter is measured in a few micrometres and is compressively stressed rather than tensile. The trade-off is a very thin layer: a 15 um compound zone is not a structural case, and it should not be specified where the part will be ground, machined or heavily run in.
The Chemistry of an Active Salt Bath
The working medium is a mixture of alkali cyanates and alkali carbonates, usually based on potassium and sodium salts, held molten at the treatment temperature. The active constituent is the cyanate ion, and nitriding power is governed by the cyanate concentration in the melt rather than by any nominal salt brand. Two reactions matter. Cyanate decomposes at the bath temperature to release nitrogen and carbon at the steel surface, and it simultaneously converts to carbonate, which is inert. As treatment continues the cyanate is consumed and carbonate accumulates, so the bath must be periodically regenerated by adding fresh cyanate-bearing salt and by removing or tolerating the carbonate build-up.
Because the melt composition drifts, bath control is a chemical process, not a timer. Cyanate concentration is titrated at intervals, commonly every shift or every few hours of production, and the result drives the additions. In practice the cyanate content is kept inside a fairly narrow band, often quoted in the region of 30 percent to 40 percent by weight depending on salt system and the layer wanted, and the bath is also checked for carbonate, cyanide, iron content and moisture. Air or a gas mixture is introduced through a distribution pipe at the bottom of the crucible, both to agitate the melt and to keep its chemistry uniform; without agitation the sludge accumulates at the bottom and the parts in the lower part of the basket see a different activity from those near the top.
The presence of cyanide in the melt, formed as an intermediate in the cyanate chemistry, is the reason this process carries heavy environmental obligations. Modern salt systems and regeneration practice are designed to minimise cyanide, but the melt, the drag-out, the rinse water and the sludge all remain regulated streams. Any user of liquid nitriding must have a documented waste route, an oxidising or neutralising stage for cyanide-bearing rinse water, and a disposal contract that matches local regulation. The equipment and the waste route should be treated as part of the process capability, not as an afterthought.
Layer Structure: Epsilon Plus Gamma Prime, Without Zeta
The characteristic advantage claimed for the salt-bath process is the phase mix it produces. In a properly controlled bath the compound zone consists of the epsilon nitride Fe3N together with the gamma prime nitride Fe4N, and it is essentially free of the zeta nitride Fe2N. The zeta phase is the iron nitride with the highest nitrogen content, about 11.0 wt% to 11.35 wt%, and it is hard but brittle with a marked tendency to porosity. Keeping it out of the layer is what allows a nitrocarburised surface to tolerate light impact and running-in contact that would crack a zeta-rich layer.
The epsilon phase carries 5.7 wt% to 11.0 wt% nitrogen and, because carbon is also absorbed, it is strictly a carbonitride in which carbon partially substitutes for nitrogen in the hexagonal lattice. That carbon take-up is the reason the salt-bath layer is more ductile and more corrosion-resistant than a pure nitride layer of the same thickness. The gamma prime phase beneath it, at 5.7 wt% to 6.1 wt% nitrogen, is tougher still and provides the graded transition into the diffusion zone, where nitrogen sits in interstitial solid solution in ferrite and as fine alloy nitride precipitates. Below that, unchanged base metal.
| Region | Phases present | Typical thickness | Function |
|---|---|---|---|
| Outer compound zone | Epsilon carbonitride, often with a thin surface oxide after post-oxidation | 8 um to 18 um | Wear resistance, anti-scuffing, corrosion resistance |
| Inner compound zone | Gamma prime nitride | 2 um to 7 um | Tough transition, resists cracking under contact load |
| Diffusion zone | Nitrogen in solid solution plus fine alloy nitrides | 0.05 mm to 0.40 mm | Fatigue strength, support for the compound zone |
| Core | Unchanged base microstructure | Remainder | Strength and ductility as supplied |
Temperature, Time and What Controls Depth
Treatment time is short by nitriding standards. Most production cycles run from 30 minutes to 3 hours, with 90 minutes to 2 hours typical for a 10 um to 20 um compound zone. Temperature sits at 560 C to 580 C for most ferrous work, and rising to 590 C to 600 C accelerates compound zone growth but also pushes towards porosity and a coarser structure. The diffusion zone grows slowly at these temperatures, so the process is chosen for surface properties, not for deep case: if 0.5 mm of case is needed, this is the wrong process and a gas or plasma nitriding cycle of 10 h to 30 h is required instead.
Two process details shape the result more than any catalogue parameter. The first is preheating. Parts are degreased, dried and preheated to roughly 350 C to 400 C before immersion, which prevents the moisture and lubricant film from disturbing the bath and reduces thermal shock on thin sections. The second is the load arrangement and agitation. Parts must be separated so that the melt circulates between them, and hollow parts must be oriented so that trapped air escapes and salt drains; a tube immersed horizontally with closed ends will show a soft band where the salt never reached the surface.
| Parameter | Typical setting | What it changes |
|---|---|---|
| Bath temperature | 560 C to 580 C | Layer growth rate, porosity, epsilon to gamma prime ratio |
| Immersion time | 30 min to 180 min | Compound zone thickness mainly, diffusion depth secondarily |
| Cyanate concentration | Titrated and held in a narrow band | Nitriding potential, layer thickness, surface nitrogen content |
| Agitation air flow | Set by bath size and load | Chemical uniformity and temperature uniformity through the melt |
| Preheat temperature | 350 C to 400 C | Distortion, bath recovery time, surface cleanliness |
| Post-oxidation | Oxidising salt or oxidising aqueous stage after the nitriding step | Surface colour, corrosion resistance, running-in |
Which Steels Respond, and How Hard They Get
Any ferrous material can be nitrocarburised; what changes is the hardness and the depth achieved. Plain carbon and low-carbon steels form a compound zone readily but the diffusion zone is soft, so the surface hardness after treatment typically falls in the range of 350 HV to 650 HV. Low-alloy steels containing chromium, molybdenum, aluminium, vanadium or titanium develop fine alloy nitrides in the diffusion zone and reach roughly 800 HV to 1100 HV in the compound zone. High-chromium and austenitic stainless steels can exceed 1000 HV to 1200 HV at the surface because chromium nitride forms readily, but the same reaction removes chromium from solid solution and degrades corrosion resistance, which has to be accepted knowingly.
The alloying additions have a second effect that is often missed in specifications: they slow diffusion. A steel that is rich in nitride-forming elements gets a harder but shallower layer than a plain carbon steel treated in the same bath for the same time, so a case depth specification written for a carbon steel tube cannot simply be transferred to a chrome-moly or stainless tube. Thickness must be specified per material and demonstrated on a coupon of that material.
For tube and pipe products the common substrates are the weldable structural and pressure grades, the quenched and tempered chrome-moly grades used for hydraulic and mechanical tube, and the free-machining and case-hardening grades used for fittings and adaptors. Heat-treated and cold-drawn condition matters: cold work is partly relieved at 570 C, so a heavily cold-drawn tube will relax and can change straightness or length slightly, and this must be accounted for in the drawing before treatment.
Post-Oxidation and Corrosion Performance
The compound zone left by the salt bath is grey and only moderately corrosion resistant on its own. A post-oxidation step, either in a separate oxidising salt at a lower temperature or in an oxidising aqueous stage, converts the outermost fraction of a micrometre into a black iron oxide that seals surface porosity and raises salt-spray performance considerably. This is why nitrocarburised parts are usually supplied black rather than grey.
Even with post-oxidation, the corrosion resistance is a thin-film property and should not be compared with galvanising, zinc-nickel plating or a painted system. It is adequate for indoor storage, for oiled assemblies and for short outdoor exposure, and it is not adequate for coastal or immersion service without an additional coating. Corrosion testing should be quoted together with the test standard, the duration and the acceptance criterion, because a salt-spray result without a stated duration and criterion means nothing. Relevant methods are the neutral salt spray test of ISO 9227 and ASTM B117, and for threaded or coated assemblies the relevant product standard may impose its own schedule.
A second, less obvious benefit of post-oxidation is running-in. The oxide film is micro-porous and retains oil, which reduces scuffing during the first hours of sliding contact; this is the reason the process is popular on hydraulic rods, spool valve bores and piston rings.
Distortion, Growth and Dimensions
Because there is no phase change and no quench, distortion is small and predictable. The treated surface grows by a few micrometres, typically 2 um to 8 um per surface depending on layer thickness, and the growth is uniform on all treated surfaces. A tube treated on both inside and outside therefore keeps its wall thickness essentially unchanged, and a tube treated on one surface only will grow on that surface and may bow slightly. Straightness after treatment should be specified numerically, and any thread or seal surface that must remain untreated should be masked mechanically or left with a machining allowance.
Threads deserve special attention. A nitrocarburised thread gains a hard, low-friction surface that resists galling, which is a benefit for repeated assembly, but the slight growth can tighten the fit. Where class of fit is critical, the thread is either masked during treatment or cut with allowance, and the acceptance gauge is checked after treatment rather than before.
Environmental, Health and Compliance Obligations
Any heat treater running a cyanate bath operates under environmental permits that cover cyanide-bearing materials. The obligations that a purchaser should be able to see evidence of are: a documented chemical control regime with titration records, a waste route for spent salt, sludge and rinse water with a licensed contractor, an oxidising destruction stage for cyanide in rinse water, fume extraction with scrubbing over the bath, personal protective equipment and training records, and emergency procedures for salt contact and for water ingress into the bath. Water entering a molten cyanate bath is the single most dangerous event in the process, because it flashes to steam and ejects salt; parts and tools must be dry before immersion.
From a product compliance viewpoint, the treated part itself is a diffusion layer in steel and does not constitute a coating of regulated substances, but the process chemicals are subject to restriction and authorisation regimes in major markets and to transport rules for cyanide-bearing salts. Where a customer requires a declaration, the heat treater's process chemical list, not the finished part, is the relevant subject. Bath sludge must never be treated as ordinary steel scrap.
Inspection and Acceptance of a Nitrocarburised Tube
Acceptance rests on sectioning a coupon treated in the same load, because every meaningful measurement is destructive. Surface hardness is measured by the Vickers method under low load per ISO 6507-1 or ASTM E384; on very thin layers the load must be low enough that the indentation depth stays below about one tenth of the layer thickness, otherwise the reading reflects the softer substrate. Compound zone thickness and phase constitution are read from a polished and etched cross-section prepared per ASTM E3 and etched per ASTM E407 practice, and the report should state total compound zone thickness, the epsilon and gamma prime fractions, and whether any zeta phase or porosity is present.
The diffusion zone is characterised by a hardness or nitrogen traverse, and the result is reported as a depth at a defined hardness limit rather than as an unqualified case depth. Surface condition after post-oxidation is checked by visual comparison against a colour reference and, where corrosion resistance is a requirement, by neutral salt spray to ISO 9227 or ASTM B117 at a stated duration. Adhesion and toughness are covered by a bend or impact test on a coupon, where the acceptance is absence of flaking or cracking of the compound zone. Finally, for thin-walled or precision tube, the dimensional report after treatment is as important as the metallurgical one.
Where Liquid Nitriding Fits Against Gas and Plasma Nitriding
All three processes put nitrogen into a steel surface; they differ in what they can offer a production line. The salt bath heats the whole load by immersion, so it is fast, uniform and effective on complex shapes and on internal surfaces that would lose a plasma. It is the cheapest way to obtain a 10 um to 20 um epsilon-rich layer on a large number of small-to-medium parts. Its drawbacks are the environmental burden, the difficulty of masking selected areas, the risk of salt drag-out into blind holes, and the fact that a tube longer than the crucible cannot be treated at all.
Gas nitriding in a retort offers very deep cases and easy control of atmosphere, and it can process loads that are too tall for a salt pot, but cycles are long and the layer tends to be gamma prime rich unless deliberately pushed. Plasma nitriding offers selective treatment through masking, low distortion, good control of the compound zone, and no salt waste stream, but it needs fixturing that keeps a glow on the surface of interest, and long small-bore tubes are difficult. The selection question is therefore: what layer, what geometry, what cycle time, and what waste infrastructure is available.
| Item | Salt-bath nitrocarburising | Gas nitriding | Plasma nitriding |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical temperature | 560 C to 580 C | 500 C to 560 C | 480 C to 560 C |
| Typical cycle | 0.5 h to 3 h | 10 h to 60 h | 4 h to 30 h |
| Compound zone | Epsilon plus gamma prime, no zeta | Gamma prime or epsilon, controllable | Gamma prime or epsilon, highly controllable |
| Selective masking | Difficult | Possible with stop-off | Easy and reliable |
| Long tube handling | Limited by crucible size | Good | Good with vertical fixturing |
| Waste stream | Cyanide and cyanate bearing, regulated | Ammonia handling | None of significance |
Mistakes That Turn Into Rejections
The most common failure is a specification that asks for a case depth, when the process can only deliver a compound zone. A purchase order stating a case depth of 0.3 mm and a nitrocarburised layer of 15 um is internally contradictory, and whichever party interprets it at inspection time will reject the other. The second common failure is acceptance by appearance: colour varies with oxidation and cooling, and a uniform grey part can be metallurgically correct while a black part can be porous.
The third is measuring hardness with a load that is too high for the layer, producing a low reading that has nothing to do with the process. The fourth is treating a part with blind holes or overlapping joints without drain and vent provisions, leaving salt pockets that bleed out later and corrode the part from the inside. The fifth is forgetting that the layer cannot be machined afterwards: if a finishing cut or a grind is planned after treatment, the layer must be thickened by the stock to be removed, or the operation must be moved before the treatment.
FAQ
Q: How deep is the layer produced by liquid nitriding?
The compound zone is normally 8 um to 25 um and the diffusion zone below it ranges from about 0.05 mm to 0.40 mm depending on steel and cycle length. The process is chosen for surface wear properties, not for a deep structural case.
Q: Why is zeta nitride avoided in a salt bath layer?
Zeta, Fe2N, carries about 11.0 wt% to 11.35 wt% nitrogen and is the hardest and most brittle of the iron nitrides, with a strong tendency to porosity. A layer free of zeta tolerates impact and running-in contact without cracking, which is the practical reason the epsilon plus gamma prime structure is preferred.
Q: Can the inside of a hydraulic tube be treated by immersion?
Yes, provided the tube is open at both ends, oriented so the salt can circulate and drain, and free of blind pockets. Salt trapped in a closed volume will bleed out after treatment and cause corrosion, so drain paths must be designed before the part is sent for treatment.
Q: What hardness can be expected on different base steels?
Plain carbon steel typically reaches 350 HV to 650 HV, low-alloy nitriding steels with chromium, molybdenum, aluminium or titanium reach about 800 HV to 1100 HV, and high-chromium or austenitic stainless grades can exceed 1000 HV to 1200 HV at the surface at the cost of corrosion resistance.
Q: Does liquid nitriding replace galvanising for corrosion protection?
No. A post-oxidised compound zone gives useful protection for indoor storage and oiled assemblies, but the layer is only a few micrometres of oxide over a 20 um case and is not equivalent to a zinc coating. For outdoor, coastal or immersion service an additional coating system is required.
Q: How is bath chemistry controlled during production?
By titrating the cyanate concentration at defined intervals and adding fresh cyanate-bearing salt to hold it inside a narrow band, while monitoring carbonate, cyanide, iron and moisture. Agitation through a distribution pipe keeps the melt uniform, and the records of those titrations are the evidence that the process was in control.
Q: Is dimensional change after treatment predictable?
Growth is typically 2 um to 8 um per treated surface and is uniform, with no quench distortion because the treatment is fully ferritic. Straightness and any critical thread fit should still be specified as measured values before and after treatment rather than assumed.





