Oct 25, 2024 Leave a message

ERW versus SAWL Welded Steel Pipe: Process, Range and Inspection

Two Different Answers to the Same Question

ERW and SAWL pipe both begin as flat steel and both end as a cylinder with a longitudinal seam, which is why they are so often compared on price alone. The similarity stops there. Electric resistance welded pipe is formed from coiled skelp and joined by resistance heating with no filler metal, at speeds of tens of metres per minute. Longitudinal submerged arc welded pipe is formed from discrete plates, usually by the JCOE or UOE route, and joined by arc welding under a flux bed with filler wire, at a fraction of that speed. The process difference sets the wall thickness, the diameter, the seam length, the toughness of the weld and the inspection method that follows.

In API SPEC 5L terminology, electric welded product is classed as EW, which covers what the trade calls ERW and its high frequency variant HFW. Submerged arc welded product is classed as SAW, with the longitudinal variant written SAWL in the trade and the helical variant SAWH, the latter being the spiral pipe used for large diameter, moderate pressure lines.

How an ERW Seam Is Actually Made

Skep is uncoiled, edge trimmed and formed through a series of rolls into a cylinder, and the two edges are brought together under pressure. A high frequency current, in the hundreds of kilohertz range, is applied either by contact shoes or by an induction coil, and the current concentrates at the edge faces because of the proximity effect. The edges reach welding temperature and are forged together by squeeze rolls, expelling a small amount of metal as an internal and external flash, which is then trimmed. No filler metal is added, so the weld composition is essentially the base metal composition.

Two consequences follow. Because no filler is used, the seam chemistry is inherited from the coil, which means the coil's sulphur level and cleanliness control the quality of the seam. Because the heating and forging cycle is extremely fast, the seam cools rapidly and can contain hard constituents, which is why ERW pipe is normally given a seam heat treatment - induction or resistance annealing of the weld zone - to restore toughness and to avoid a hard line that would be susceptible to cracking in sour service or during field bending. For demanding duties the whole pipe may be normalized rather than the seam alone.

How an SAWL Seam Is Made

A plate is cut to width, its edges are milled or planed to a welding preparation, and it is formed progressively. In the JCOE route the plate is pressed first into a J, then a C, then an O shape, and the edges are squeezed together and tack welded; in the UOE route it is crimped, pressed into a U, then into an O, and expanded at the end. The longitudinal seam is then welded from the inside and from the outside by submerged arc welding, with the arc buried under a granular flux that shields the pool and stabilises the arc. After welding, the pipe is mechanically expanded or sized to bring the diameter and ovality into tolerance.

Submerged arc welding is a high heat input process. That is an advantage for thick walls, because the large molten pool penetrates reliably through the full wall with a double sided sequence, and a disadvantage for toughness, because the coarse grain heat affected zone next to the fusion line can be embrittled unless the plate chemistry, the heat input and the post weld cooling are all controlled. This is the technical reason SAWL specifications for low temperature and sour service place so much weight on welding procedure qualification and on weld metal and heat affected zone impact testing.

Size Range, Capacity and Process Comparison

Item ERW / HFW SAWL (LSAW) SAWH (spiral)
Feedstock Hot rolled coil Plate Hot rolled coil
Typical outside diameter 21.3 mm to 610 mm 406 mm to 1500 mm 219 mm to 3000 mm
Typical wall thickness 1.5 mm to 20 mm 6 mm to 40 mm and above 5 mm to 25 mm
Seam arrangement One longitudinal weld One or two longitudinal welds Continuous helical weld
Filler metal None Welding wire and flux Welding wire and flux
Production speed High, continuous coil operation Low, discrete plate operation Medium
Diameter tolerance Tight, from sizing rolls Good after expansion Moderate
Seam length per metre 1 m per metre of pipe Order of metres per length Longest per pipe
Relative unit cost Lowest for compatible sizes Highest Between the two

Read the table as a capability boundary rather than a ranking. An ERW mill cannot make a 1219 mm pipe and an SAWL mill cannot economically make a 168 mm pipe, so for most projects the process choice is already decided by the diameter and wall thickness in the line design.

Weld Quality, Toughness and the Sour Service Question

An ERW seam is metallurgically a forged joint. When the process parameters are correct and the seam is heat treated, the weld is essentially indistinguishable from the parent metal and the pipe performs as a homogeneous cylinder. When the process drifts - dirty edges, wrong squeeze, insufficient heat input, oxidation at the edge faces - the result is a cold weld or a stitch defect, which is a planar flaw lying exactly in the plane of the hoop stress and therefore difficult to size by radiography. This is why ERW pipe is inspected by ultrasonic or electromagnetic methods directed at the seam rather than by radiography.

An SAWL seam is a cast weld with a fusion line, a coarse grain zone and a reinforcement profile. It is more forgiving of edge condition but introduces the toughness problem described above, and the weld metal properties depend on the consumable lot. Radiography is effective on SAW because the likely defects are volumetric, though ultrasonic testing is also used for planar defects and for the heat affected zone.

For sour service, ISO 15156 / NACE MR0175 requires hardness control in the weld and heat affected zone, normally to a maximum of about 22 HRC for carbon steels. Meeting that limit in an ERW seam depends on the efficiency of the seam heat treatment and on the steel chemistry; meeting it in an SAW seam depends on the consumable selection and the heat input. In both cases it must be demonstrated by hardness traverse testing, not assumed from the process name.

Dimensions, Ends and Code Implications

Diameter and ovality tolerances drive the cost of the girth weld. ERW pipe from a sizing mill is typically the most dimensionally consistent product in the small to medium size range, which is why it dominates distribution lines and mechanical piping where automatic welding or grooved couplings are used. SAWL pipe is expanded after welding to reach its tolerance, and the expansion also relieves part of the welding residual stress and improves the roundness needed for a consistent root gap on the mainline spread.

Pipe ends are bevelled to the angle and root face stated in the purchase order, and the bevel quality on a thick wall SAWL pipe is a separate operation that must be specified. In design codes, the longitudinal joint factor for API 5L EW and SAW product is taken at the full value, but that only holds when the pipe is ordered and certified to the relevant product specification level and non-destructive examination annex. A pipe sold as EW but supplied against a lower examination level is not the same design input.

Choosing Between Them on a Real Project

The decision sequence is short. Fix the design pressure, the diameter and the allowable wall thickness from the pressure equation and the code design factor. Check whether any mill can produce that wall at that diameter in the preferred process. Then compare the installed cost, which includes the pipe price, the coating price, the girth weld cost per joint and the inspection cost, not the pipe price alone.

In practice, distribution lines, water mains, piling, structural tube and mechanical service lines up to about 610 mm are almost always ERW or HFW. Mainline transmission at 508 mm and above, high pressure and thick wall duty, cold climate lines needing drop weight tear test performance, and offshore export lines are SAWL territory. Spiral pipe occupies the large diameter, moderate pressure segment where the lower plate width requirement is an advantage. Where the seam must be eliminated altogether - small diameter high pressure flowlines, instrument lines, and some sour service scopes - the answer is seamless, not welded, and the comparison then shifts to wall uniformity and cost per metre.

Inspection and Documentation Differences

An ERW order should specify seam ultrasonic or electromagnetic examination, a flattening test, weld tensile testing and the hydrostatic test, together with a weld seam heat treatment record. An SAWL order should specify radiographic or ultrasonic examination of the seam, weld tensile and bend testing, heat affected zone impact testing at the required temperature, dimensional checks after expansion and the welding procedure qualification record. Both need a certificate to EN 10204 type 3.1 as a baseline, with heat number traceability through coating and delivery.

FAQ

Q: Are ERW and HFW the same thing?
HFW is a subset. Electric resistance welding is the general term, and high frequency welding is the modern variant using contact or induction current in the hundreds of kilohertz, which is what almost all current ERW mills actually run.

Q: Why is ERW pipe not radiographed?
The characteristic defects of an ERW seam are planar and aligned with the weld plane, which radiography detects poorly. Ultrasonic and electromagnetic seam inspection are the appropriate methods and are what API 5L requires.

Q: Can SAWL pipe be used at small diameters?
It is technically possible but rarely economic, because plate handling and forming cost per metre rise sharply as diameter falls. ERW or seamless dominate below about 406 mm.

Q: Which process gives better toughness?
Neither process wins automatically. ERW relies on clean steel and effective seam heat treatment, while SAWL relies on plate toughness, consumable selection, heat input control and heat affected zone impact testing.

Q: Does the process affect sour service qualification?
Yes. ISO 15156 / NACE MR0175 requires hardness limits of about 22 HRC in weld and heat affected zone, so the seam heat treatment for ERW and the welding procedure for SAWL must both be qualified by hardness traverse testing.

Q: What single document prevents a wrong substitution?
A purchase description that states standard, grade, product specification level, manufacturing process, diameter, wall thickness with tolerances, length, impact test temperature, examination annex and coating system. If the process is not named, the mill may supply whichever is cheaper.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry