Nov 01, 2024 Leave a message

Single-Pass vs Double-Pass Welding in Steel Pipe Production

Three Words That Are Constantly Confused: Pass, Side and Seam

Most arguments about single pass and double pass welding in pipe production are really arguments about three different variables that happen to share a vocabulary. A pass is one traverse of the heat source along a joint. A side is one face of the joint - inside or outside of the pipe wall. A seam is a longitudinal joint line in the finished pipe, and a large pipe may have one seam or two, spaced apart around the circumference. A joint can be welded from one side in three passes, welded from both sides in one pass each, or welded as a single pass that closes the full wall thickness in one event. Unless the specification states which of the three is meant, two suppliers can both claim compliance and deliver different products.

In pipe mill practice the terms carry a further layer of meaning. In submerged arc welding of heavy wall line pipe, a "single pass" often means one pass per side, that is a root pass inside the pipe and a single cap pass outside, with the full wall closed in two traverses. In high frequency welding, single pass is literal: the strip edges are forged together in one continuous event regardless of wall thickness, because there is no deposited metal. Both are legitimately described as single pass welding and they are not remotely the same process.

What Single Pass Welding Can and Cannot Do

A true single pass closes the full joint section in one traverse. It is achievable in three situations: thin wall where the arc or the resistance heating penetrates the entire thickness; a joint geometry designed for complete penetration from one side, such as a square butt with a backing system or a narrow gap with a consumable insert; and solid state processes such as high frequency welding where the mechanism does not depend on melt depth.

Autogenous gas tungsten arc welding is the classic single pass technique for thin wall tube. Without filler, the achievable full penetration thickness is limited to roughly 2.5 mm to 3 mm in a square butt preparation, and rather more with a carefully controlled preplaced filler or a consumable insert. Orbital single pass welding of this kind is used for instrument tubing, heat exchanger tube to tubesheet joints and small diameter stainless lines where the inside of the joint must remain smooth and free of oxide. Plasma welding extends the single pass thickness somewhat because the keyhole mode produces a stable full penetration weld with a very uniform bead.

The advantage of a genuine single pass is speed and reproducibility: there is no interpass cleaning, no interpass temperature management, no risk of slag entrapment between layers, and the whole joint sees one thermal cycle. The limitation is thickness, and the second limitation is defect tolerance: a single pass has no second chance, so a lack of penetration or a burn through at the root cannot be repaired by a subsequent layer and must be excavated entirely.

Double Pass and Multi Pass Welding: Root, Fill and Cap

As wall thickness rises, the joint is built up in layers. A typical heavy wall submerged arc joint has a root pass on the inside of the pipe, then one or more fill passes, then a cap pass on the outside, and on very heavy wall a second inside pass before the outside sequence. Each pass remelts and refines part of the previous pass, which is metallurgically beneficial: the grain structure of the earlier deposit is refined and the columnar structure of the original solidification is broken up, giving better Charpy energy and a lower susceptibility to hydrogen assisted cracking.

The cost of multiple passes is direct: more arc time per metre, more wire and flux, more interpass cleaning, controlled interpass temperature, and a longer thermal exposure of the base metal. Heat input per pass must also be managed so that the cumulative effect does not over temper or, in the case of quenched and tempered line pipe, degrade the base metal properties in the coarse grained heat affected zone.

The reason multi pass is nonetheless mandatory in critical service is defect control and toughness. A two pass joint per side on 20 mm wall is not simply a faster version of a six pass joint; the individual pass thickness, the number of layers, the sequence and the interpass temperature all become essential variables that must be captured in the welding procedure specification and proven by procedure qualification.

Comparison of Joint Build Up Options

Variable Single pass, one side Two pass, one side each Multi pass, both sides
Practical wall thickness Up to about 3 mm autogenous, more with insert or keyhole About 6 mm to 16 mm depending on process and grade 16 mm and above, unrestricted by pass count
Typical processes GTAW, plasma, HFW, laser SAW with one inside and one outside pass SAW, FCAW, GMAW, SMAW
Heat input per joint Lowest Moderate Highest cumulative
Grain refinement of deposit None Partial Progressive, best toughness
Interpass cleaning Not applicable Limited Required at every layer
Defect recovery None, defect means full excavation Limited Defect in a fill pass may be removed before the next layer
Relative productivity Highest per metre High Lowest, but required for heavy wall
Governing quality risk Lack of penetration, burn through, incomplete fusion Fusion line defects, cap profile Slag entrapment, hydrogen cracking, distortion

Heat Input, Cooling Rate and the Heat Affected Zone

Heat input per pass is calculated as arc voltage multiplied by current multiplied by 60, divided by one thousand times the travel speed in millimetres per minute, which yields kilojoules per millimetre. A single pass at high current and moderate speed concentrates that energy into one thermal cycle; several passes with lower current distribute the same total energy over a longer time and a wider zone, but each individual pass cools faster because it is thinner.

For carbon and low alloy line pipe this matters in two directions. Too high a heat input in a single pass produces a wide coarse grained heat affected zone with poor upper shelf toughness and, in niobium and vanadium microalloyed steels, excessive softening. Too low a heat input, particularly on thick wall with a fast cooling rate, produces hard martensitic or bainitic structures that are susceptible to hydrogen cracking, which is why preheat and interpass temperature are specified together with a maximum hardness acceptance criterion. In sour service to ISO 15156 and NACE MR0175 the hardness limit on the weld and heat affected zone becomes a design requirement rather than a preference, and it is the pass structure that determines whether the limit is achievable.

For austenitic stainless and duplex steel the same logic produces a different rule. Single pass welds on duplex stainless have a high ferrite content in the as welded root unless a balancing filler with austenite promoting nitrogen is used, and multi pass welding tempers the earlier passes, improving phase balance and corrosion resistance. Duplex procedures therefore normally specify a minimum number of passes, a maximum interpass temperature around 150 °C, and a heat input band rather than a single maximum.

Procedure Qualification: Where Pass Structure Becomes Legally Binding

A welding procedure specification is only valid for the essential variables it was qualified for. Under ISO 15614-1 the number of passes, the welding process, the filler classification, the joint design, the position, the preheat and interpass temperature and the heat input range are all essential or non essential variables with defined qualification ranges, and changing from single pass to multi pass, or from one side to both sides, normally requires requalification or at least a documented revision supported by the existing qualification range.

ASME BPVC Section IX treats the same question through the essential variables listed in QW-250 for each process, and API 1104 together with ISO 13847 govern pipeline girth welding in the field, where a change in pass sequence on a given wall thickness and grade is a procedure change, not an operator preference. The practical consequence for a purchaser is that a mill or a contractor cannot legitimately switch from a two pass to a single pass sequence to save time unless the qualified procedure and the supporting mechanical tests cover the new sequence.

Supporting tests are not limited to tensile strength. Procedure qualification normally includes transverse tensile, root and face bend or side bend, Charpy impact at the specified test temperature with notch locations in weld metal and heat affected zone, hardness traverses across the weld, and for corrosion resistant alloys a ferrite count or an intergranular corrosion test to the relevant ASTM practice.

Defects, Inspection and the Value of Pass Discipline

In a single pass joint the inspection question is simple: is the joint fully penetrated and fully fused along its whole length? Ultrasonic testing is normally used on the finished weld, with radiographic testing where the geometry permits, and the acceptance level should be named when the purchase order is placed. In a multi pass joint the inspection problem becomes a three dimensional one, because a defect may sit between layers and be masked from both surfaces.

Interpass inspection is therefore part of the procedure, not an optional extra. Slag must be removed and the surface inspected visually or by magnetic particle testing before the next layer, particularly on the sidewall where slag lines form. Interpass temperature must be measured and recorded, because an uncontrolled rise in interpass temperature on thick wall is a common cause of coarse grain and reduced toughness in the completed joint even when each individual pass looks correct.

For pipe mill longitudinal seams, the finished seam is inspected by ultrasonic testing to ISO 10893-11 with the technique and reference reflector defined by the specification, and by radiographic testing where required, with the acceptance levels agreed at the time of order. Delamination or lack of fusion oriented parallel to the seam is best found ultrasonically, while slag and porosity are found readily by radiography; the two methods are complementary rather than alternatives.

Two Seams Rather Than Two Passes: A Separate Distinction

A large diameter longitudinal pipe may be manufactured with two longitudinal seams placed opposite each other, roughly 180 degrees apart, which is how very wide plate can be formed into a diameter that a single seam plate width could not reach. This is a double seam pipe and it has nothing to do with double pass welding, although the two terms are routinely mixed up in trade literature.

The engineering consequences are real. A double seam pipe has twice the length of welded joint per metre, which doubles the inspection coverage requirement, and the seam positions must be reported because they govern the orientation of girth weld intersections and the layout of field coating repairs. API SPEC 5L and the applicable dimensional standard limit the seam arrangement and require the seam weld to meet the same quality requirements as a single seam. A purchaser who orders "double welded pipe" expecting a heavy wall two pass product can easily receive a double seam pipe instead, so the requirement must be written as seam arrangement, pass sequence and wall thickness range separately.

Choosing the Sequence for a Given Application

Thin wall tube, instrument lines, heat exchanger tubes and small diameter precision products are single pass territory, where autogenous or keyhole welding gives a clean bore and a repeatable result with minimal distortion. Medium wall line pipe up to roughly 16 mm is efficiently produced with one pass inside and one outside, a sequence that closes the wall with two thermal cycles and keeps productivity high while still allowing the cap to refine the root region.

Heavy wall transmission pipe, pressure vessel shells, high pressure station piping and anything in sour or low temperature service belongs in the multi pass category, where the pass count is set by wall thickness and by the toughness and hardness requirements rather than by productivity. In those cases the pass sequence should be specified by the purchaser in terms of maximum pass thickness, maximum heat input per pass, interpass temperature range and the required notch locations for impact testing, because those four variables, not the nominal number of passes, are what actually control the finished joint properties.

Across all three categories the same verification logic applies: the procedure must be qualified for the sequence actually used, the operator must be qualified for the process and position, the consumables must be controlled and dry, and the records must allow a third party to reconstruct which pass was made with which parameters on which heat of steel.

FAQ

Q: Is double pass welding stronger than single pass welding?
Not automatically, but it is more consistent in heavy wall. Multiple passes refine each earlier deposit and allow defects between layers to be removed, so the finished joint usually has better toughness and a lower defect rate than a single pass on the same thickness. On thin wall, a well controlled single pass is entirely adequate.

Q: Does single pass mean welded from one side only?
Not necessarily. Single pass refers to one traverse of the heat source. A joint can be welded in a single pass from each side, which is two passes in total, and this is the standard sequence for medium wall submerged arc line pipe.

Q: What is the maximum wall thickness for a single pass weld?
For autogenous gas tungsten arc welding without filler, roughly 2.5 mm to 3 mm. Keyhole plasma and laser welding reach somewhat more, and high frequency welding closes the full wall in one event up to about 20 mm. Above those limits a layered sequence is required.

Q: Why is interpass temperature controlled in multi pass welding?
Because the accumulated heat changes the cooling rate of each subsequent pass, coarsens the heat affected zone and can degrade toughness and hardness. Procedures therefore set a maximum, often in the region of 250 °C for carbon steel and lower for duplex stainless steel.

Q: Is a double seam pipe the same as a double welded pipe?
No. Double seam pipe has two separate longitudinal seams positioned around the circumference, usually opposite each other, to allow a large diameter from a limited plate width. Double welded pipe refers to a joint welded from both the inside and the outside.

Q: Can the pass sequence be changed after the procedure is qualified?
Only within the qualification ranges of the governing standard. Under ISO 15614-1 and ASME BPVC Section IX a change in the number of passes or in the number of sides welded is an essential variable for most processes, so the sequence cannot be altered to save time without requalification or a documented revision of the procedure.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry