Heat Treatment Is Chosen From the Required Property, Not From the Steel Alone
Quenching, normalising and tempering are the three treatments most often named when a tube order specifies a heat treated condition, but the choice between them is not a matter of preference. It follows from three inputs: the hardenability of the grade, the wall thickness that must be cooled through, and the property the finished component needs at its service temperature. A thin wall tube and a heavy wall tube of the same analysis can end up with measurably different hardness after an identical quench, because the cooling rate at the mid-wall is set by the wall itself. That single fact explains most of the disputes that arise when a mill certificate is compared with a hardness check on a delivered tube.
The vocabulary is standardised: ISO 4885 defines the heat treatment terms, and GB/T 7232 provides the Chinese equivalent, so process names can be translated without ambiguity. What is not standardised is the process window for a given product. Each product standard fixes the treatment it permits, and the purchase order has to point to that standard rather than to a generic instruction to heat treat.
The Three Core Treatments and What Each One Does
Quenching heats the steel above its critical temperature so that austenite forms, then cools fast enough to suppress the diffusion-controlled transformations and produce martensite or bainite. The result is the highest hardness and strength available from the analysis, accompanied by low ductility and high internal stress. The cooling medium sets the severity of the quench: still air is the mildest, then forced air, oil, polymer solution, water, and brine as the most severe. Selecting a medium is a compromise between achieving the required depth of hardening and avoiding quench cracking, and thin wall tube is far more sensitive to cracking than a solid bar because both surfaces are being cooled at once.
Normalising heats the steel above the critical temperature and cools it in still air. The purpose is structural rather than strengthening: it refines an overheated or coarse grain structure, homogenises segregation from casting or from a hot working pass, removes residual stress from cold working or welding, and produces a uniform ferrite-pearlite structure with predictable and repeatable mechanical properties. Normalising is the default condition for many carbon and low alloy pressure tube grades because it gives a stable baseline that a purchaser can verify with a tensile test and a metallographic check.
Tempering follows quenching, and reheats the martensitic structure to a temperature below the critical range to allow controlled precipitation and recovery. Tempering is what converts an unusable hard brittle structure into a serviceable one. The temperature chosen controls the trade-off: a low temper around 150 to 250 degrees Celsius retains high hardness for wear resistance, a mid temper around 400 to 550 degrees Celsius gives a strong tough structure, and a high temper above 600 degrees Celsius produces the best toughness and creep resistance at lower strength. Time at temperature matters as much as temperature itself, and a specification that fixes only the tempering temperature without a minimum hold is incomplete.
Annealing Variants That Buyers Frequently Confuse
Annealing is not a single treatment. Full annealing heats above the critical range and cools slowly, usually in the furnace, producing maximum softness and machinability. Process annealing, also called intercritical or subcritical annealing, heats below the lower critical temperature to soften cold worked steel without a full transformation, and it is the treatment used between cold drawing passes. Spheroidise annealing holds near the lower critical temperature for a long time so that cementite coalesces into spheroids, which is the preferred condition for heavy cold forming and for machining of medium and high carbon steel. Stress relief annealing heats well below the transformation range, typically in the range of 550 to 680 degrees Celsius for carbon and low alloy steel, and holds long enough for residual stress to relax by creep without changing the microstructure.
For austenitic stainless tube the equivalent treatment is solution annealing: heating to a temperature that dissolves carbides, commonly 1040 degrees Celsius and above for the 304 and 316 families as required by ASTM A312, followed by rapid cooling in water or by another method fast enough to prevent carbide reprecipitation. The rapid cooling is not optional, because slow cooling through the sensitising range precipitates chromium carbides at the grain boundaries and destroys intergranular corrosion resistance.
| Treatment | Typical temperature band | Cooling | Resulting structure | Typical tube application |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Full anneal | 30 to 50 C above upper critical temperature | Furnace, slow | Coarse ferrite and pearlite, softest condition | Tube for severe cold forming or heavy machining |
| Process anneal | Below lower critical temperature | Air or furnace | Recovered, partially recrystallised | Interpass treatment in cold drawing |
| Spheroidise anneal | Just below lower critical, long hold | Very slow | Spheroidised carbides | Bearing and high carbon tube stock |
| Normalise | 30 to 50 C above upper critical temperature | Still air | Fine ferrite and pearlite | Carbon steel pressure tube, low temperature service |
| Quench and temper | Austenitise, then temper according to strength target | Water, polymer or oil, then air | Tempered martensite or bainite | High strength line pipe, high yield casing |
| Stress relief | 550 to 680 C for carbon and low alloy steel | Furnace to below 300 C | Unchanged, stress reduced | Cold drawn tube, welded tube after forming |
| Solution anneal | 1040 C and above for austenitic grades | Rapid water quench | Single phase austenite, carbides dissolved | Stainless tube for corrosive service |
Product Standards Prescribe Which Treatment Applies
API SPEC 5L ties the delivery condition to the grade and to the toughness requirement. For PSL2 pipe the standard requires a defined heat treatment or thermomechanical route, and the permissible combinations of grade, pipe type and delivery condition are restricted: a high grade such as X70 or X80 in the quenched and tempered or thermomechanically processed condition is normal, while the same grade produced by a plain normalising route may not be permissible for the specified toughness. In welded pipe the heat treatment applies to the pipe body and separately to the weld seam, and the seam heat treatment condition has to be verified as part of the weld qualification rather than inferred from the body treatment.
In the boiler and heat exchanger family the requirements are explicit and non-negotiable. ASTM A333 Grade 6 low temperature tube is supplied normalised, because the impact toughness at low temperature depends on a fine grain ferrite-pearlite structure. ASTM A335 chromium-molybdenum grades and their ASTM A213 counterparts are supplied normalised and tempered, with the two steps both required: a P22 tube that has been normalised but not tempered will fail the tensile and impact requirements even though it looks correct on the outside. For Grade 91 the standard practice is to normalise in the range of about 1040 to 1080 degrees Celsius and temper in the range of about 730 to 800 degrees Celsius, and the tempering step is what develops the fine precipitates that give the grade its elevated temperature strength. Omitting or drifting outside those windows produces a tube that meets dimensional requirements and fails in service.
Cold finished precision tube follows a different logic. Under EN 10305-1 the delivery condition suffix fixes what heat treatment, if any, the tube receives after the final forming pass, ranging from hard as formed through stress relieved and annealed to normalised. The suffix must appear on the order, because the mechanical properties quoted in a quotation often refer to the annealed condition while the delivered tube may be in the hard condition.
Wall Thickness, Hardenability and the Cooling Rate Problem
Hardenability describes how deep a steel will harden under a given cooling rate, and it is measured by the end quench test described in ASTM A255. For tube, the practical question is whether the mid-wall of the heaviest section reaches the critical cooling rate. A water quench on a thin wall tube can produce near full martensite, while an oil quench on a heavy wall tube of the same analysis may produce only a shallow hardened case with a soft ferrite-pearlite core. The resulting tube has a hardness gradient through the wall, which translates into a strength gradient and into an uneven response to machining.
There is a second geometric effect unique to hollow sections: the inner surface is cooled by the quench medium on a smaller radius, and the heat extraction from the bore is often less efficient than from the outside surface, particularly if vapour cannot escape. The result is that the bore surface may transform later than the outside surface, generating a different residual stress pattern from a solid bar of the same steel. This is why tube quench specifications frequently require an internal flush or a dedicated bore quench nozzle, and why the hardness survey should include a mid-wall or bore location, not just an outside diameter reading.
Distortion, Decarburisation and Atmosphere Control
Quenching distorts. Thin wall tube is especially prone to ovality change, bow and diameter growth, because the section has low resistance to bending once it is hot and soft. Purchasers of quenched and tempered tube should therefore state the straightness and ovality limits that apply after heat treatment, and should expect the mill to correct them by straightening followed by a low temperature stress relief, because straightening reintroduces residual stress. A tube that is straight but carries unrelieved straightening stress will move again during machining.
Furnace atmosphere controls surface quality. An oxidising atmosphere produces scale that must be removed and that consumes wall thickness at the surface, so the specified wall tolerance must account for the cleaning allowance or the furnace must be atmosphere controlled. A decarburising atmosphere removes carbon from the surface layer, which lowers the hardness of the outer skin and can cause a quench crack initiation site; the depth of decarburisation is measurable by metallographic methods such as ASTM E1077 and should be limited in the purchase specification for tube that will be machined after heat treatment. Protective atmospheres based on nitrogen or on exothermic gas, and vacuum furnaces for stainless grades, avoid both problems at higher operating cost.
Verification: What the Test Certificate Should Prove
A heat treatment is only as good as the evidence that it happened. The mill test certificate should state the treatment by name with the austenitising temperature, the tempering temperature, the holding time and the cooling medium for the batch or the continuous run, not merely the words quenched and tempered. Mechanical verification should include a tensile test to ASTM A370 taken from the finished tube, hardness measurements at defined locations, and impact testing where the standard or the service requires it, with the test temperature stated. Metallographic examination of grain size to ASTM E112 is useful where a normalising treatment has to refine a coarse structure, and a hardness traverse across the wall is the practical check for through-wall uniformity.
Two acceptance rules prevent most problems at goods receiving. First, verify the condition against the product standard, not against the supplier description: if the standard requires normalising and the certificate says stress relieved, the tube is non-conforming however good the tensile results appear. Second, re-test after any shop fabrication heat treatment, because welding, bending and stress relieving all modify the structure that the mill established, and in the chromium-molybdenum grades a post-weld heat treatment outside its window can degrade toughness below the original acceptance level.
FAQ
Q: Why does the same steel give different hardness after the same quench on two tube sizes?
Because hardness after quenching depends on the cooling rate at the location measured, and the cooling rate is governed by wall thickness and by how efficiently the quench medium reaches the bore. A thicker wall cools more slowly at mid-wall, so less martensite forms and hardness is lower even though the analysis and the furnace cycle were identical.
Q: Can normalising replace quenching and tempering for a high strength tube?
Normalising produces a ferrite-pearlite structure with moderate strength and good toughness, so it cannot reach the strength levels of a quenched and tempered tube of the same analysis. Where the product standard or the design requires a high yield strength in a heavy wall, quenching and tempering is the applicable route and normalising is not an equivalent substitute.
Q: Why must Grade 91 tube be tempered after normalising?
Normalising from about 1040 to 1080 degrees Celsius produces a hard martensitic structure with very low toughness. Tempering in the range of about 730 to 800 degrees Celsius allows the precipitation that provides creep strength and restores toughness. A normalised but untempered Grade 91 tube is unfit for pressure service.
Q: Is stress relief the same as annealing?
No. Stress relief heats below the transformation range, typically 550 to 680 degrees Celsius for carbon and low alloy steel, and relaxes residual stress without changing the microstructure, so strength is largely retained. Annealing transforms or substantially softens the structure and reduces strength considerably.
Q: What controls temper embrittlement in chromium-molybdenum tube?
Susceptibility depends on the steel composition, especially the phosphorus, tin, antimony and arsenic content and the presence of alloying elements that promote segregation, and on cooling slowly through the embrittling temperature range. The control measures are to specify acceptable chemistry, to cool rapidly through the critical range after tempering, and to avoid post-weld heat treatment cycles that hold the steel in that range longer than necessary.
Q: Does a mill certificate for a heat treated tube guarantee the condition of the weld seam?
Not automatically. In welded tube the seam undergoes a different thermal history from the body, and the seam treatment must be qualified and verified separately, for example by hardness traverse across the seam and by the weld tensile and bend tests required by the product standard.





