How Radiography Sees Inside an X52 PSL2 Weld
Radiographic testing forms a shadow image of the pipe wall on a detector. A source emits X-rays or gamma radiation, the beam passes through the weld, and the intensity reaching the detector is reduced by an amount that depends on the material thickness and density along each path. A crack, a slag line or a pore presents less steel than the surrounding sound weld, so more radiation reaches the detector behind it and the imperfection appears as a darker area on the processed image. The physics is straightforward; the engineering difficulty lies in making that shadow sharp, correctly exposed, and comparable from one pipe to the next.
On an API 5L X52 PSL2 line pipe the weld seam is the object of interest. For a 323.9 mm outside diameter, 12.7 mm wall pipe with a specified minimum yield strength of 359 MPa and a tensile range of 455 MPa to 760 MPa, the weld is normally a double-sided submerged-arc or a high-frequency electric resistance seam, and the imperfections that matter are lack of fusion at the side wall, incomplete penetration at the root, transverse and longitudinal cracks in the weld metal and heat-affected zone, slag inclusions and clustered porosity. Every one of these is volumetric or subsurface in nature, which is precisely why radiographic examination belongs in the PSL2 inspection plan and penetrant testing does not replace it.
What PSL2 Status Changes About the Examination
PSL1 pipe is delivered on the basis of mechanical properties and a hydrostatic test. PSL2 adds a defined chemical composition, mandatory tensile testing of the pipe body, a weld tensile test for welded product, Charpy impact testing of the weld and heat-affected zone when specified, and non-destructive inspection of the weld seam under Annex E of API SPEC 5L. For a PSL2 X52 heat, carbon is typically capped at 0.24 percent for seamless product and 0.22 percent for welded product, with phosphorus at 0.025 percent and sulphur at 0.015 percent maximum. Those tighter limits exist to buy toughness and weldability, and they change what the radiograph should look like: a cleaner steel produces fewer inclusion indications, so a high count of elongated slag indications on a supposedly PSL2 pipe is a chemistry and steelmaking signal, not simply a weld defect.
PSL2 also raises the traceability requirement. The radiograph is linked to a heat number, a pipe number and a weld shift, and the examination record becomes part of the inspection documents supplied with the material test certificate. A purchaser comparing two offers for the same nominal X52 PSL2 specification should therefore establish, before award, whether the quoted price includes full-length radiographic examination of the weld seam or only a sampling percentage, because the difference in test coverage is larger than the difference in steel cost on most orders.
Choosing the Radiation Source and Technique
Source selection is driven by wall thickness, by the required contrast on the detector, and by the geometry of the joint. X-ray generators give high flux and adjustable energy, which shortens exposure and improves contrast on thin and medium walls; gamma sources are portable, need no power and penetrate thick sections that would require a large accelerator. Se-75 is the usual gamma choice for wall thickness from roughly 6 mm to 20 mm, Ir-192 covers the range from about 12 mm to 40 mm, and Co-60 is reserved for heavy wall and for large-diameter thick sections. For a 12.7 mm X52 wall, a 200 kV to 250 kV X-ray set or a Se-75 source both give workable images; the X-ray set will normally produce the better contrast and the shorter exposure at the weld.
| Source | Practical wall range | Strength on X52 pipe | Limitation |
|---|---|---|---|
| X-ray, 160 kV to 250 kV | Up to about 20 mm | High contrast, short exposure, fine control of energy | Needs power and cooling, larger focal spot at high output |
| Se-75 gamma | About 6 mm to 20 mm | Portable, good contrast in the medium wall range | Short half-life, source replacement cost, fixed energy |
| Ir-192 gamma | About 12 mm to 40 mm | Portable, high penetration, fast on heavy wall | Lower contrast on thin sections, larger effective source size |
| Co-60 gamma | Above about 40 mm | Very high penetration | Poor contrast below 30 mm, heavy shielding requirement |
Technique class matters as much as source. ISO 10893-6 defines radiographic examination of the weld seam of steel tubes, and it separates technique classes that differ in the permitted geometric unsharpness and in the image quality that must be demonstrated. A purchaser who simply asks for radiographic testing without naming the technique class may receive a class that is adequate for general screening but not for the critical weld examination implied by a PSL2 specification for a high-pressure line.
Image Quality, Density and Geometric Unsharpness
Three numbers decide whether a radiograph is usable. The first is image quality, demonstrated by an image quality indicator placed on the source side of the weld, either a wire type to ISO 19232-1 or a hole type to ASTM E1025 and ISO 19232-2. The second is film density or, for digital detectors, the grey value and signal-to-noise ratio; conventional film is normally read in the density range of 1.8 to 4.0, with 2.0 to 3.0 being the working band for pipe welds on most procedures. The third is geometric unsharpness, which grows with source size and with the distance between the defect and the detector and shrinks with source-to-film distance.
| Parameter | Reference | Working value for 12.7 mm X52 wall |
|---|---|---|
| Image quality indicator | ISO 19232-1, ISO 19232-2, ASTM E1025 | Wire IQI W10 or W13, or hole type 2T, depending on technique class |
| Film density | ISO 11699-1 film systems, ISO 10893-6 | 1.8 minimum, 2.0 to 3.0 typical, up to 4.0 on thin sections |
| Geometric unsharpness | ISO 10893-6 technique class | 0.2 mm to 0.32 mm, calculated from source size, wall and distance |
| Source-to-detector distance | Derived from the unsharpness limit | Increased until the calculated unsharpness falls below the limit |
| Weld coverage | API SPEC 5L Annex E | Full weld length plus at least 10 mm of parent metal on each side |
The unsharpness calculation is worth stating explicitly because it is where field procedures most often drift. Unsharpness equals the product of the effective source size and the defect-to-detector distance divided by the source-to-detector distance. Halving the source size or doubling the distance both improve sharpness; moving the source closer to make the exposure shorter always degrades it. With a gamma source whose effective size is 3 mm and a 12.7 mm wall examined in single-wall technique, the geometry must be arranged so that the resulting value stays within the technique class limit, which in practice means a source-to-detector distance of several hundred millimetres for a small-diameter pipe.
Film, Computed Radiography and Direct Digital Detectors
Film remains the reference medium because it is simple, robust and universally accepted, and film systems are classified from C1 to C5 under ISO 11699-1, with the lower numbers denoting finer grain and higher contrast. For X52 line pipe weld examination a C3 or better film system is typical; a C5 system will struggle to show a 0.3 mm slag line at 3 percent of wall thickness. Processing must be controlled by the chemistry manufacturer's parameters, with density and developing temperature recorded, because an over-developed film raises density and hides fine detail behind grain.
Computed radiography using a photostimulable imaging plate is covered by ASTM E2033 and ISO 10893-7 style digital practice, and it offers a wider exposure latitude, which is valuable when wall thickness varies along a spiral weld. Direct digital detector arrays are covered by ASTM E2698; they give immediate images and high throughput on a mill line but require a detector with sufficient pixel pitch and a demonstrated basic spatial resolution, and the system must be qualified by comparing its detection capability against film on representative imperfection samples. In every digital route the fundamental rule is the same: the digital image must demonstrate at least the same image quality indicator visibility as the film technique it replaces, and it must be stored with its acquisition parameters and be retrievable in an unaltered form.
Exposure Geometry, Coverage and Weld Orientation
Single-wall single-image technique is the default for pipe up to about 400 mm outside diameter that can be accessed internally, and it gives the best defect contrast because radiation passes through one wall only. Double-wall single-image technique is used for small-diameter and heavy-wall pipe where internal access is impossible, but it superimposes two walls and two weld images, which reduces the detectable imperfection size. For the longitudinal seam of a large-diameter LSAW or SSAW pipe, the seam is exposed with the beam directed at the weld centreline and the source positioned so that the beam is normal to the weld within a few degrees; an angled beam elongates the image of a planar defect and can make lack of fusion more visible, but the angle must be recorded and kept within the procedure limit or the same defect may be missed on a re-shoot.
Coverage is a contractual number, not an inspector's choice. Annex E of API SPEC 5L requires the weld seam of PSL2 pipe to be examined over its full length unless a reduced coverage is specifically agreed, and the standard practice is to radiograph the complete seam with overlapping exposures so that no length is seen only at the edge of a film. For a 12 m length of 323.9 mm pipe, that is a continuous series of exposures around the full circumference, each including at least 10 mm of parent metal on either side of the weld and overlapping its neighbour enough to avoid an unexamined strip between images.
Repair welds are re-examined over the repaired zone plus adjacent material, because repair welding introduces new heat-affected material and a second thermal cycle that can crack the original weld metal. A repaired area that is radiographed only at its centre will often look acceptable while the fusion line at its edge carries the defect that prompted the repair in the first place.
Reading the Image: Imperfection Types and Their Signatures
Interpretation is a discipline of matching image morphology to welding physics. Lack of side-wall fusion appears as a straight or slightly wavy dark line parallel to the weld edge, with a density that is usually uniform along its length, and it is often the most under-reported defect on line pipe because a slightly angled beam can hide it. Incomplete penetration at the root appears as a dark line along the weld centreline, frequently interrupted, and on a double-sided submerged-arc weld it is distinguished from an internal bead line by its sharp edges and its continuous length.
Cracks appear as fine, dark, often branching lines that are irregular in width, and a transverse crack crosses the weld perpendicular to its axis, which makes it easy to miss if the beam is exactly normal to the seam. Slag inclusions are elongated dark lines or strings, usually with tapered ends, aligned along the weld direction, and they are more common in multi-pass submerged-arc welds where inter-run cleaning was incomplete. Porosity appears as rounded dark spots, and its significance depends entirely on distribution: scattered isolated pores of less than about 0.5 mm are generally acceptable, while clustered or aligned porosity in the root region usually indicates a consumable or moisture problem and should be treated as a process failure rather than a random imperfection.
Undercut appears as a dark line at the weld toe on the parent metal side, and it is a thickness reduction rather than a discontinuity, so its evaluation must consider the remaining wall rather than only its length. Tungsten inclusions, which appear as bright, highly absorbing spots, are an artefact of gas tungsten arc welding and indicate electrode contact; they are a welding process finding, not a random image defect.
Acceptance Under API 5L Annex E and ISO 10893-6
Acceptance criteria must be quoted from the standard invoked by the purchase order, not invented at the viewing bench. Annex E of API SPEC 5L sets maximum permissible imperfection sizes for the weld seam, expressed as a fraction of wall thickness and as absolute length limits, and ISO 10893-6 provides the corresponding examination method. The practical consequence is that the same image can be acceptable for one class of service and rejectable for another, so the procedure must state which criteria apply before the first exposure is made.
In day-to-day evaluation three rules dominate. Any crack indication in the weld or heat-affected zone is unacceptable, with no size tolerance. Elongated slag or lack-of-fusion indications are compared against a length limit that scales with wall thickness, so a 12.7 mm wall X52 weld is judged against a smaller absolute length than a 25 mm wall pipe of the same grade. Isolated porosity is accepted within a size and count limit, but aligned or clustered porosity is judged as a linear indication because its effect on the effective load-bearing section is not the same as that of scattered pores.
A rejected length is not automatically scrap. It is ground out and repaired under a qualified welding procedure, and the repaired area is re-examined. What must not happen is a repair that is ground and blended without re-examination, because the blending operation can leave a defect at the fusion boundary that the original radiograph never showed.
Data Integrity, Radiation Safety and Report Content
A radiograph that cannot be traced is of little use in a dispute. The report should identify the pipe number, heat number, grade and PSL level, wall thickness and outside diameter, the weld type and position, the source type and its activity or kilovoltage, the source-to-detector distance, the exposure time, the image quality indicator type and the value read, the density or grey value, the film system or detector identification, the examining procedure number and the acceptance criteria applied. For digital images, the raw data must be preserved along with the processing parameters, since an image that has been filtered and re-saved cannot be re-evaluated at the original sensitivity.
Radiation safety is a non-negotiable part of the method. Gamma sources must be handled under a controlled area with surveyed boundaries, and exposures on a fabrication site must be coordinated with all other trades in the area. The practical consequence for a buyer is scheduling: radiographic examination of the weld seam competes with coating, hydrostatic testing and handling at the mill, and a specification that requires radiography after coating is unworkable, because the coating absorbs radiation and the pipe cannot be opened for internal access without damaging it.
FAQ
Q: Does API 5L X52 PSL2 pipe require 100 percent radiography of the weld seam?
PSL2 welded pipe requires non-destructive inspection of the weld seam under Annex E of API SPEC 5L, and the weld is examined over its full length unless a reduced coverage is specifically agreed in the purchase order. The examination may be radiographic or ultrasonic, or another method agreed between purchaser and manufacturer, so radiography is one permitted route rather than a universal mandate.
Q: Which radiation source suits a 12.7 mm wall X52 pipe?
Both a 200 kV to 250 kV X-ray set and a Se-75 gamma source give usable images in that wall range, with the X-ray set normally providing better contrast and shorter exposure. Ir-192 becomes more attractive above about 12 mm when portability matters, but its lower contrast on thin sections makes it a poorer choice for detecting small slag lines in a 12.7 mm wall.
Q: What film density should be specified for pipe weld radiographs?
A working range of 2.0 to 3.0 is typical, with 1.8 as the practical minimum and up to 4.0 permissible on thin sections where contrast is limited. Density must be measured at the weld and recorded, because an under-developed film reduces contrast while an over-developed film adds grain that hides fine indications.
Q: Can digital radiography replace film for PSL2 weld examination?
Yes, provided the digital system is qualified to show at least the same image quality indicator visibility as the film technique it replaces, and provided the acquisition parameters and raw data are retained. Computed radiography to ASTM E2033 and direct digital detector arrays to ASTM E2698 are both accepted routes when the qualification is documented.
Q: Why are transverse cracks in the weld so easy to miss?
Because a transverse crack lies in a plane perpendicular to the weld axis, so a beam directed exactly along the weld produces a narrow image that can fall below the visible threshold. Detection depends on beam angling within the procedure limit and on the use of two exposures at slightly different angles on critical welds.
Q: What happens to a pipe that fails radiographic acceptance?
The imperfection is located, ground out under a controlled procedure, and the remaining wall thickness is verified; the area is then repair welded under a qualified procedure and re-examined over the repaired zone plus adjacent material. Pipes that cannot be repaired within the permitted wall reduction are rejected and segregated from the accepted lot.





