What Electric Resistance Welding Really Is
Electric resistance welding forms a pipe from a slit strip, brings the two edges together in a forming section, and joins them by heating the edges with an electric current while squeezing them with rolls. No filler metal is added, no flux is used and no shielding gas is required: the joint is a solid state forge weld produced by heating the steel into a plastic condition and pressing the oxidised faces out of the interface. That single mechanism explains both the economics and the weakness of the process. It is fast and consumes little material, and it leaves a narrow weld whose quality depends almost entirely on how cleanly the edges were prepared and how precisely the current and squeeze were controlled.
The variants that buyers meet in specifications are not cosmetic. They differ in how the current is delivered, at what frequency the current alternates, whether the current is induced in the strip or passed through contact shoes, and how the resulting seam is heat treated and inspected. Each combination produces a different weld microstructure and a different defect population, which is why the welding route belongs in the purchase order on any ERW pipe destined for pressure service.
AC and DC Seam Welding: Two Different Electrical Answers
Alternating current seam welding uses the mains frequency supply, historically at 50 Hz or 60 Hz, and relies on the fact that current flows in the strip edges where the circuit closes through the weld V. The great advantage is simplicity: large transformers, heavy currents and thick walls can be welded without conversion equipment, and the early large diameter ERW mills were built around this approach. The limitation is equally structural. At low frequency the current spreads through a wide path in the strip rather than concentrating at the edge, so the heating zone is broad, the heat affected zone is wide, and the process is difficult to control on thin wall where the strip can be overheated before the edges reach forging temperature.
Direct current seam welding rectifies the supply and delivers a unidirectional current, which concentrates the heating pattern far more tightly and gives much better control of the weld nugget position. DC systems are easier to regulate on thin wall and on high speed mills, and the narrower heating zone reduces the width of the heat affected zone and the amount of upset metal that has to be trimmed. The trade off is capital cost and the need for solid state conversion, which is why DC is the default on modern small and medium diameter mills while AC remains in service on older heavy wall equipment. For a purchaser the practical question is not which is theoretically better but whether the mill can demonstrate, through its procedure qualification and its routine ultrasonic inspection results, that its particular combination holds a consistent weld on the wall thickness being ordered.
Frequency Bands: What Changes When You Raise the Frequency
The welding frequency decides how deeply the current penetrates the strip edge, because current crowds toward the surface as frequency rises. Low frequency current spreads through the full wall thickness; high frequency current concentrates in a thin skin at the edge, heats it rapidly and lets the squeeze rolls complete the weld before heat conducts away. The consequence is that frequency selection is coupled to wall thickness: high frequency suits thin wall and moderate wall at high line speed, while heavy wall needs a lower frequency or a different process entirely so that the full thickness reaches forging temperature.
| Band | Typical operating range | Heating character | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Power frequency AC | 50 Hz to 60 Hz | Broad current path, wide heat affected zone, slow thermal response | Heavy wall, older large diameter mills, low line speed |
| Low frequency | Up to about 1 kHz | Deep penetration, good through thickness heating | Thicker wall where full section heating is needed |
| Medium frequency | About 1 kHz to 10 kHz | Intermediate spread, easier power control than mains frequency | Mid wall ranges, mills converting from AC |
| High frequency induction | Typically 100 kHz to 500 kHz | Shallow skin heating at the edge, very fast, clean surface | Thin wall and standard wall at high speed, wide material range |
| High frequency contact | Typically 100 kHz to 500 kHz | Current fed through sliding contacts directly into the strip | Standard wall, lower energy per metre than induction |
Higher frequency is not automatically higher quality. A very high frequency on a heavy wall heats only the outer skin of the edge, and the centre of the interface may never reach welding temperature, producing a seam that passes a superficial check and fails later as a cold weld. That failure mode is invisible from outside and is the reason the industry pairs high frequency welding with continuous non-destructive seam inspection rather than with visual acceptance.
Induction versus Contact: Energy, Surface and Consistency
Induction welding places a coil around the strip edge. The alternating field induces eddy currents in the edge, heating it without any physical contact, so there is no electrode wear, no contact marking and no dependence on the strip surface being electrically clean at the contact point. The heating is stable and the same coil setting works across a range of materials, which is why induction is the more forgiving route on stainless and on coated or pickled strip. The cost is electrical efficiency: a substantial share of the energy is lost in the coil and in the surrounding structure, so power consumption per metre is higher.
Contact welding feeds current into the strip through sliding copper or copper alloy contacts positioned close to the weld point. The current path is short, the electrical efficiency is high, and energy consumption per metre is markedly lower than induction at the same wall. The penalty is mechanical: contacts wear, they mark the strip surface, they need constant pressure and cooling control, and the weld quality is sensitive to contact condition, to strip surface scale and to any fluctuation in contact resistance. A worn or badly seated contact produces an unstable current path, which shows up as a variable weld and as a higher rate of penetrators and incomplete fusion.
Weld Seam Metallurgy and In-Line Heat Treatment
The weld and its adjacent heat affected zone are heated above the transformation temperature and then cooled in air at the mill's line speed. On as-welded ERW pipe this leaves a narrow band of harder, coarser microstructure along the seam, with a hardness peak in the heat affected zone that can exceed the parent metal by a considerable margin. On plain carbon structural pipe, that seam is usually acceptable. On line pipe, and particularly on PSL2 grades and on anything intended for sour or low temperature service, the seam is normally heat treated in line by induction or by a gas fired normalising unit, which refines the grains and brings the hardness back toward the parent metal level.
Whether the seam is normalised, and whether the whole pipe is subsequently normalised, is a specification item rather than a mill preference. A seam heat treatment that is too cool leaves a hard band and a notch; one that is too hot grows the grain and drops the low temperature toughness. Purchasers ordering pipe to API 5L or to ASTM A53 should require the heat treatment condition to be stated, and on sour service orders should require hardness traverses across the seam to demonstrate that the weld, the heat affected zone and the parent metal all sit below the ceiling set by ISO 15156.
The Defects That Matter and How They Are Found
ERW seams fail in a small number of recognisable ways, and every one of them is a consequence of the process rather than of the steel. A cold weld occurs when the edges reach the rolls below forging temperature: the interface is bonded only intermittently, the fracture surface shows a flat unbonded plane instead of a ductile cup and cone, and the joint can pass a pressure test at low stress before failing in service. A penetrator is a remnant of the oxidised edge or of the upset material driven into the weld interface and left there as a flat oxide inclusion. A hook crack runs from the interface into the wall along the flow lines of the upset metal and is the classic ERW seam defect on older mills and on heavy wall.
Stitch welding, where the weld is intermittent rather than continuous, arises from power fluctuation or from a momentary loss of contact, and it is one of the reasons continuous seam inspection is specified. Internal and external flash must be trimmed consistently: a heavy internal flash interferes with pigging and with ultrasonic coupling, while a badly trimmed external flash leaves a stress concentration at the seam. Detection relies on automated ultrasonic inspection of the seam, commonly to the ISO 10893 series, often combined with electromagnetic flux leakage for the body and with a hydrostatic test. Ultrasonic inspection must be set up with a reference standard containing drilled holes or machined notches at the weld interface, and the acceptance limits must be agreed in the purchase order, since a mill inspecting to its internal standard and a purchaser expecting a tighter limit will disagree at the receiving gate.
Size, Wall and Where ERW Stops Being the Right Answer
ERW is at its best from small nominal sizes up to roughly 610 mm outside diameter in standard wall, at high production rates and with tight diameter control that comes from forming from strip. It is the standard route for water lines, structural tube, scaffold tube, fence and low pressure service, and it is increasingly used for line pipe in small and medium diameters where the seam can be inspected reliably. Its limits are wall related rather than diameter related: as wall rises, the frequency has to fall and the process window narrows, so heavy wall large diameter pipe is normally made by longitudinal submerged arc welding from plate, where the weld is made with filler metal and can be inspected radiographically in both directions.
Where the duty is severe, the choice should acknowledge the seam. Very low temperature service with stringent drop weight tear test requirements, sour service with hardness limits across the seam, and any application where the weld cannot be inspected from both surfaces are all cases where a purchaser should either demand a fully normalised ERW product with certified seam inspection or move to a submerged arc welded or seamless route. Specifying ERW and then discovering at the coating stage that the seam hardness fails the sour service criterion is an expensive way to learn the distinction.
What Belongs in an ERW Pipe Order
An order that will be judged fairly at receipt names the product standard and edition, the grade and product specification level, the outside diameter and wall with tolerance class, the welding frequency band or the acceptable process range, whether the seam is heat treated and to what condition, the inspection method and acceptance level for the seam, the hydrostatic test pressure and hold time, and the certificate type. Adding the reference standard used for the ultrasonic set-up, and the requirement that the certificate reports seam inspection results rather than only a statement of compliance, closes most of the documentation gap.
On the receiving side, the checks that find real problems are cheap: measure diameter and ovality at both ends, check wall thickness at several points around the circumference including the seam, look for a straight, continuous external flash trim and an even heat tint along the seam, confirm that the marking carries the heat number that appears on the certificate, and cut one length for a flattening or bend test if the order allows destructive sampling. A seam that opens on a flattening test was never welded properly, whatever the inspection report said.
FAQ
Q: What does ERW stand for in steel pipe production?
Electric resistance welding. The strip edges are heated by electric current and pressed together by rolls to form a solid state forge weld without filler metal, flux or shielding gas.
Q: What is the difference between high frequency induction and contact welding?
Induction welding heats the edge with an encircling coil and no physical contact, giving stable heating and no electrode wear at the cost of higher energy use. Contact welding feeds current through sliding contacts, consuming less energy but requiring careful contact maintenance and leaving surface marks.
Q: Why does welding frequency depend on wall thickness?
Because current concentrates near the surface as frequency rises. High frequency heats only a thin skin at the edge, which suits thin and standard wall at speed, while heavy wall needs a lower frequency so the full section reaches forging temperature.
Q: Does ERW pipe have a heat treated weld seam?
Many line pipe and pressure orders require the seam to be normalised in line by induction or gas firing to refine the grain and reduce hardness in the heat affected zone. Whether the seam is heat treated, and to what condition, must be stated in the order.
Q: What defects are typical of an ERW weld seam?
Cold weld from insufficient forging temperature, penetrators formed by oxide driven into the interface, hook cracks running from the interface into the wall, stitch welding from power or contact interruption, and inconsistent flash trim. Continuous ultrasonic seam inspection is the standard defence.
Q: Up to what size is ERW pipe normally produced?
ERW is economically applied from small nominal sizes up to roughly 610 mm outside diameter in standard wall. Above that, and in heavy wall, longitudinal submerged arc welded pipe made from plate is the usual route.





