Nov 05, 2024 Leave a message

LSAW vs DSAW Steel Pipe: Seam Geometry, Sizing and Selection

Two Names, Three Processes: Clearing Up the Terminology First

In purchase orders and mill datasheets the abbreviations LSAW and DSAW are used loosely, and that looseness is where most specification disputes begin. LSAW stands for longitudinal submerged arc welding and describes the seam direction: the coil or plate is formed so that the two edges run parallel to the pipe axis and are joined by one straight seam. DSAW stands for double submerged arc welding and describes the welding practice rather than the seam direction: the seam is welded from the inside and from the outside, normally one pass per side. A longitudinal pipe welded on both faces is therefore LSAW and DSAW at the same time, while a helical pipe welded on both faces is a spiral double-sided product, usually written SSAW or HSAW.

That overlap is the reason two mills can both answer a tender written around DSAW and still offer physically different pipes. When the wording of a specification arrives, the first question to settle is which seam direction the mill intends to deliver, because longitudinal and helical shells differ in dimensional capability, in the weld metal consumed per tonne, in the way the seam is inspected, and in how the finished pipe behaves when it is bent, laid and pressurised. The comparison below treats LSAW as the longitudinal family and DSAW as the double-sided practice applied either longitudinally or helically.

Forming Routes Behind a Longitudinal Seam

A longitudinal mill forms a plate or a heavy coil into a cylinder and closes the gap before welding. Three routes dominate. In the JCOE route the plate is crimped at both edges, pressed into a J profile, then into a C profile, and finally closed in an O press; the seam is welded, the pipe is cooled, and the whole length is mechanically expanded on a mandrel to improve roundness and to release part of the forming stress. In the UOE route the plate is formed by a U press and an O press before welding and expansion, which suits high volume output over a narrow diameter band. Roll bending routes form the shell progressively between rolls and are flexible for short runs and heavy walls, but the operator has more influence over ovality.

All three routes normally end with a sizing or expansion step, and that step is what a buyer should examine when two mills both claim LSAW capability. Expansion tightens diameter tolerance and straightness and evens out the yield strength around the circumference, but it also consumes part of the available ductility, so the expansion ratio has to be set together with the plate chemistry and the delivery condition. A mill that welds and sizes without expansion can still meet the standard, yet the ovality and the end alignment of consecutive pipes become harder to hold when the line is to be joined by automatic girth welding on site.

Seam Geometry and What It Costs in Weld Metal

In a longitudinal pipe the seam runs the full length of the shell in a straight line on each face. In a helical pipe the strip is fed at an angle to the axis and the seam spirals around the body, so the seam is longer than the pipe itself and the number of seam metres per tonne of steel rises. The practical consequences are more wire and flux, more heat input into the shell and a larger share of the pipe length that has to pass through seam inspection. Against that, the helical seam spreads its length over the whole circumference and crosses the neutral axis repeatedly, so a spiral shell tolerates out-of-roundness and field misalignment comparatively well.

Both processes are submerged arc welding: the arc burns beneath a layer of granular flux, the molten pool is shielded without visible spatter, and deposition rates are high enough to weld heavy walls in a small number of passes. The single pass thickness per side is limited by the groove preparation and by the heat input the base metal will accept without loss of toughness, so thick walls are welded with several passes per side, sometimes over a gas metal arc root. For sour service the heat input window and the hardness ceiling become acceptance criteria rather than preferences, and the welding procedure has to demonstrate both on the actual plate grade and thickness.

Dimensional Capability and Practical Size Windows

Diameter range is the first filter in any tender. Longitudinal mills built around JCOE or UOE presses commonly serve the 406.4 mm to 1422 mm band, which covers transmission lines from 16 inch upward, and they reach wall thicknesses that helical mills cannot, because a straight seam can be welded from both faces along its full length without the geometry drifting. Helical mills form from relatively narrow coil and therefore reach very large diameters, up to roughly 3 m on the largest installations, but wall thickness is limited by the coil thickness available and by forming stability at the steeper helix angles used for small diameters.

Attribute Longitudinal seam, double sided Helical seam, double sided
Feedstock Wide plate or heavy coil, cut to length Narrow coil, continuous
Typical outside diameter 406.4 mm to 1422 mm 219.1 mm to 3048 mm
Typical wall thickness 6 mm to 50 mm 5 mm to 25 mm
Seam length per pipe Equal to pipe length Longer than pipe length
Roundness after expansion High, controlled by mandrel Good, sensitive to coil camber
Length flexibility Cut to order up to about 12.2 m Cut to order, long sections possible
Typical delivery condition As rolled, normalised, TMCP, quenched and tempered As rolled, TMCP, normalised
Typical product grades API 5L X52 to X80, PSL2 API 5L Gr.B to X70, PSL1 and PSL2

Length is a commercial as well as a technical variable. A 12 m pipe halves the number of girth welds compared with 6 m stock on a long spread, but road transport, yard handling and the reach of the side boom often decide the matter before any standard does. Buyers should fix length, end squareness and bevel dimensions in the order rather than relying on default mill practice, because those three items drive the cost of field welding far more than the grade designation does.

Mechanical Property Consistency Along the Body

Because a longitudinal pipe is formed from one plate, the pipe body properties follow the plate: the yield strength, the tensile strength and the Charpy energy measured in the body reflect the steelmaker heat treatment and, for thermomechanically rolled plate, the rolling schedule. Typical API 5L PSL2 windows are 359 MPa to 530 MPa yield with 455 MPa to 760 MPa tensile for X52, 448 MPa to 600 MPa with 531 MPa to 758 MPa for X65, and 482 MPa to 621 MPa with 565 MPa to 758 MPa for X70, each measured on the pipe body in the transverse direction. The spread between minimum and maximum is deliberate: it allows the mill to hit the target without drifting into a grade it cannot certify.

A helical shell behaves differently because its strength comes from narrow coil that has been rolled along one direction and then curved along another. The pipe body values remain those of the coil, but the weld and the heat affected zone occupy a larger share of the circumference, and the residual stress pattern around the spiral follows the helix rather than the axis. For a given grade, a helical pipe will usually show a wider hardness scatter across the seam than a longitudinal pipe, which is why hardness traverses and weld hardness caps are written into sour service orders regardless of seam type.

Inspection, Nondestructive Testing and Pressure Test

Seam inspection is where the two products diverge most in cost. A longitudinal pipe has one seam plane, so ultrasonic or radiographic coverage of the seam is a straightforward full length scan on two faces. A helical pipe has a seam that crosses the whole body, and the inspection has to follow the helix with the probe carriage aligned to the weld, which slows the line and needs disciplined setup. In both cases the governing documents are the API 5L requirements for weld seam inspection together with the ISO 10893 series for automated ultrasonic testing of the seam, and the usual supporting standards are ASTM E213 for ultrasonic examination of metal pipe and tubing, ASTM E309 for austenitic and similar welds, ASTM E709 for magnetic particle, ASTM E165 for liquid penetrant and ASTM E94 or ASTM E142 for radiographic examination.

Hydrostatic testing follows the API 5L pressure test clause: the holding pressure, the hold time and the fibre stress limit are calculated from diameter and wall thickness, and the mill records the chart for each pipe or each lot as the order requires. For PSL2 and for sour service, additional tests typically include a flattening or bend test, a weld tensile test, a guided bend test across the seam, Charpy tests in the weld and heat affected zone, drop weight tear testing on heavy wall transmission pipe, and hardness surveys. Where the line is to carry wet sour hydrocarbon, the material has to satisfy ISO 15156 and NACE MR0175 in addition to the product standard, and that usually forces a hardness ceiling, tighter chemistry limits and a documented heat treatment.

Which One Fits the Project

Longitudinal double-sided pipe is the natural choice for high pressure gas and oil transmission above 16 inch, for offshore lines, for cold bending and for anything where wall thickness, roundness and consistent seam toughness drive the design. The straight seam is easy to inspect, easy to radiograph and easy to repair, and the expanded shell lines up well for automatic welding. The price of those advantages is the plate width needed to close a large diameter and the cost of the press and expansion equipment, which is why the smallest economic sizes start around 16 inch.

Helical double-sided pipe wins where diameter is large, pressure is moderate and length of line is long: water transmission, slurry lines, outfall and intake lines, penstock, piling and general structural work. A helical mill can produce a 2 m or 3 m diameter pipe from coil that any steel service centre stocks, and it can change diameter by changing the forming angle rather than by changing tooling, which keeps small and mixed orders affordable. Where the same project needs a high pressure gas line and a large diameter water line, buying both from one source usually means one is being supplied outside the process that suits it best, and the specification should say so explicitly.

Common Misunderstandings in Tender Documents

The first recurring error is treating DSAW as a synonym for spiral. It is not: DSAW describes welding from both faces and can be applied to a straight seam. The second is assuming that a double-sided seam is automatically a full penetration seam; penetration depends on groove design, welding procedure and inspection, not on the number of sides welded. The third is quoting a wall thickness range without a diameter, since the two are linked through the forming route and through the mill capability, and a size that exists on paper may need a tooling change that the mill will not absorb inside the delivery window.

The fourth is accepting the grade designation as proof of toughness. X70 does not by itself promise a Charpy shelf energy at minus 20 degrees Celsius; the impact test temperature, the absorbed energy level, the specimen size and the shear area requirement have to be written out, because the same grade can be delivered as rolled or as quenched and tempered with very different transition behaviour. The fifth is leaving the weld repair rule undefined. A cap on the number of repairs per 100 m of seam, the requirement to re-examine repaired areas with the same method, and the rule on repair of the same location twice belongs in the purchase order, not in a discussion after the first rejected pipe.

Verifying a Mill Before the Order

Ask for the welding procedure specification and the procedure qualification record for the exact grade and wall thickness, not for a neighbouring size, and check that the qualified heat input range covers what the mill actually runs. Ask for a sample mill test certificate and confirm that it reports the pipe body yield and tensile values, the weld tensile result, the Charpy values with test temperature and specimen orientation, the hydrostatic test pressure and the nondestructive testing standard applied. Ask which expansion ratio is used and how ovality and end squareness are measured. These four documents tell a buyer more about the delivered pipe than any brochure claim, and they are the documents that will be checked again when a third party inspector visits the mill.

FAQ

Q: Is DSAW the same as LSAW?
No. LSAW defines a longitudinal seam direction, while DSAW defines welding from both the inside and the outside. A longitudinal pipe welded on both faces is both; a helical pipe welded on both faces is a spiral double-sided pipe, normally designated SSAW or HSAW.

Q: Which seam type gives better dimensional accuracy?
A longitudinal pipe that has been fully expanded on a mandrel normally gives the tighter combination of roundness, straightness and end alignment, which is why it is preferred where automatic girth welding is used. A helical pipe can still meet API 5L tolerances, but roundness depends more on coil quality and on the forming setup.

Q: Can a helical pipe be supplied as API 5L PSL2?
Yes. PSL2 is a specification level covering chemistry, notch toughness, testing frequency and traceability, and it can be applied to helical pipe. In practice the limiting factors are wall thickness availability and the toughness of the coil at the specified impact test temperature.

Q: What wall thickness can a longitudinal mill reach?
JCOE and UOE mills commonly deliver 6 mm to 50 mm wall in the 406.4 mm to 1422 mm diameter band, with the exact ceiling set by the press capacity, the expansion ratio and the ability to weld the groove from both faces without distortion.

Q: How is the seam of a helical pipe inspected?
By automated ultrasonic testing that follows the helix, commonly to the ISO 10893 series, supported by radiographic examination where the order requires it. Because the seam is longer than the pipe, the inspected length per pipe is greater than for a longitudinal pipe of the same size.

Q: Does seam type affect the pressure rating?
The design pressure comes from diameter, wall thickness and allowable stress, not from the seam type alone. Seam type affects the weld efficiency factor and the inspection burden, and both may be specified by the design code, so the calculation and the purchase specification have to be read together.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry