Nov 05, 2024 Leave a message

What Is Destructive Testing of Steel Pipe? Methods and Inspection Points

What Is Destructive Testing of Steel Pipe?

Destructive testing is the family of mechanical and metallurgical examinations in which a sample taken from a pipe length is loaded, bent, impacted or sectioned until it deforms or fractures. Because the sample is destroyed, the test describes the material behaviour of the heat rather than the condition of the individual length, and it is therefore performed on samples cut from the pipe ends or from sacrificial lengths. Destructive testing is complementary to non-destructive testing: radiographic, ultrasonic, magnetic particle and eddy current methods detect discontinuities without damaging the pipe, while destructive tests quantify strength, ductility, toughness and corrosion behaviour.

For line pipe, casing, tubing and pressure pipe the required tests are defined by the governing specification, and the acceptance values are stated in the same document rather than agreed case by case.

Tensile Testing

A tensile test piece is machined from the pipe body, the weld seam or the heat-affected zone as required, and pulled axially in a universal testing machine until it fractures, following procedures such as ASTM A370 or ISO 6892-1. The test yields the yield strength, tensile strength, elongation and, when an extensometer is used, the stress-strain curve from which the yield-to-tensile ratio is calculated.

Result recorded What it tells the specifier
Yield strength Whether the grade minimum has been reached and whether the upper limit is respected
Tensile strength Resistance to gross plastic overload and the basis for the elongation formula
Elongation Ductility, evaluated against the value calculated from the pipe cross section
Yield-to-tensile ratio Strain capacity, important for pipelines in seismic or permafrost areas

The geometry of the specimen matters. A full-section specimen cut from a small diameter pipe and a strip specimen taken from a large diameter pipe can give slightly different elongation values, so the applicable specimen type is stated in the specification and should be recorded on the test certificate.

Impact and Toughness Testing

Charpy V-notch testing measures the energy absorbed when a notched specimen is fractured by a swinging pendulum at a controlled temperature, following ASTM E23 or ISO 148. For PSL 2 line pipe the test is required on the base metal, the weld metal and the heat-affected zone separately, at a specified test temperature, because the three zones can behave very differently. A minimum average absorbed energy for a set of three specimens, with a separate minimum for any single specimen, is the usual acceptance criterion.

Drop weight tear testing is a supplementary requirement for transmission pipelines where resistance to ductile fracture propagation must be demonstrated. A pressed notch specimen is fractured by a falling weight and the resulting shear area is measured as a percentage of the fracture surface, with a minimum shear area and, for some specifications, a maximum lateral expansion limit.

Hydrostatic and Burst Testing

Hydrostatic testing applies internal water pressure to a complete length or a section, holding it for a specified time while the surface is inspected for leakage and, in some cases, pipe movement is measured. For welded pipe it verifies the pressure integrity of the pipe body and the weld seam. Burst testing is taken further, raising the pressure until the pipe fails, and is used for qualification of a manufacturing route or a weld procedure rather than for routine production release. Pressure is normally recorded against the calculated hoop stress, so the test result is comparable between different wall thicknesses.

Bend, Flattening and Hardness Testing

Guided bend testing evaluates the ductility of a weld and its heat-affected zone by bending a prepared specimen through a specified angle

Flattening testing compresses a pipe section between parallel plates to a specified distance and shows whether the weld or body develops cracks

Hardness testing, by Brinell, Rockwell or Vickers methods, checks the weld and heat-affected zone against the limits that apply to sour service and to certain alloy grades

Sectioning with macro examination reveals lack of penetration, incomplete fusion or weld geometry problems that survive radiography

Hardness is particularly important for casing, tubing and pipeline material intended for wet hydrogen sulfide service, where a hard zone in the weld can initiate sulfide stress cracking even though the tensile results are acceptable.

Corrosion and Metallographic Evaluation

Where pipe is intended for a corrosive duty, accelerated corrosion tests are run in media that simulate the service environment, and the corrosion rate, morphology and penetration behaviour are recorded. Metallographic examination of a polished and etched section confirms grain size, microstructure and the presence of banding, decarburisation or untempered regions that a mechanical test alone would not expose. Together with fractography, these examinations explain why a result fell outside the acceptance limits and are normally required when a heat is being investigated rather than routinely released.

Sampling and Acceptance Practice

Acceptance is based on samples taken at a defined frequency, usually one set per heat and per manufacturing run for the tests specified for the grade, with the pipe position and orientation recorded. If a specimen fails, most specifications allow a retest on a duplicate set taken from the same length or from adjacent lengths, and repeated failure results in rejection of the lot. Because the destructive test consumes material that is not shipped, the cut ends are normally left longer on production orders that call for testing. Test certificates should identify the heat number, the pipe identity, the specimen orientation and the test temperature, so that the results can be traced to the delivered lengths.

FAQ

Q: What is the difference between destructive and non-destructive testing?
Non-destructive testing examines the pipe without altering it and finds discontinuities. Destructive testing loads a cut specimen until it fails and therefore quantifies strength, ductility, toughness and corrosion behaviour.

Q: Which tests are normally required for PSL 2 line pipe?
A tensile test and Charpy V-notch impact tests on base metal, weld and heat-affected zone at the specified test temperature, together with the hydrostatic test applied to every length.

Q: Why is hardness tested on pipe welds?
Hard zones in a weld or heat-affected zone can crack in wet hydrogen sulfide service, so hardness limits are applied to protect sour-service piping and well tubulars.

Q: What does a drop weight tear test show?
It measures the shear area of a fractured specimen and indicates the pipe resistance to ductile fracture propagation, which matters for high-pressure transmission lines.

Q: Can a failed test specimen be replaced?
Most specifications allow retesting of a duplicate set from the same or adjacent lengths. If the retest also fails, the lot is rejected.

Q: Why must the test temperature be stated on the certificate?
Impact energy falls sharply as temperature drops, so a result is meaningless unless the test temperature is known and compared with the minimum design metal temperature.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry