Aug 16, 2024 Leave a message

Martensitic Stainless Steel: Grades, Hardening and Weld Limits

Definition: A Stainless Family Hardened by Martensite, Not by Nickel

Martensitic stainless steels are chromium-bearing steels in which the austenite formed at high temperature transforms to martensite on cooling, so the finished part derives its strength from a hardened crystal structure rather than from cold work or from an austenitic matrix. They are magnetic in all conditions, they can be hardened and tempered like an alloy steel, and they carry chromium in the range of roughly 11.5 % to 18 % to obtain useful corrosion resistance. Carbon is the element that makes the transformation possible, and it is also the element that limits weldability.

The family sits in a completely different design space from the 300-series austenitic grades. A 304 tube cannot be hardened by heat treatment at all; a 410 tube can be taken from roughly 200 HV to well above 400 HV with a single austenitise-and-quench cycle. That is why the martensitic grades dominate shafts, stems, blades, cutlery, moulds, bearings and wear parts, and why they appear in tubular form mainly where hardness or resistance to mild erosive wear matters more than weldability.

Standard grades in commercial use are 410 (UNS S41000), 414 (S41400), 416 (S41600) and its selenium-bearing variant, 420 (S42000), 431 (S43100), and the three high-carbon grades 440A, 440B and 440C (S44002, S44003, S44004). Product standards that cover them include ASTM A276/A276M and ASTM A479/A479M for bars, ASTM A240/A240M for plate, ASTM A268/A268M for ferritic and martensitic stainless tubing, ASTM A511 for seamless mechanical tubing, ASTM A176 for high-temperature plate, and EN 10088-2 and EN 10088-3 for the European equivalents such as 1.4006, 1.4021, 1.4028, 1.4034, 1.4057 and 1.4125.

Composition Ranges and What Each Element Is Doing

Chromium provides the passive film. At 11.5 % the film is thin but adequate for atmospheric, fresh water and mildly oxidising service; at 16 % to 18 %, as in the 440 series, corrosion resistance approaches that of a low-carbon 430 but the much higher carbon content removes most of the benefit for welding and for chloride service. Carbon raises hardenability and attainable hardness. The commercial compromise is direct: every 0.1 % of carbon added to gain hardness costs toughness, weldability and corrosion resistance.

Molybdenum in 414 and in 440C improves pitting resistance in chloride environments and raises temper resistance. Nickel in 414 and 431, at about 1.25 % to 2.5 %, lowers the martensite start temperature, improves toughness and allows a higher chromium level to be carried without excessive ferrite. Sulphur in 416 at 0.15 % minimum is a deliberate free-machining addition that breaks the chip in automatic screw machines at the cost of a marked drop in corrosion resistance and ductility. Selenium in 416Se does a similar job with slightly different machining behaviour.

Silicon and manganese are residual deoxidation elements and are specified with maxima rather than targets. Phosphorus and sulphur in the non-free-machining grades are held low, typically 0.040 % and 0.030 % maximum respectively under ASTM A276, because both segregate to grain boundaries and reduce toughness in the hardened condition.

Grade (UNS) Carbon % Chromium % Other % Hardening temperature Typical hardness after temper Typical use
410 (S41000) 0.15 max 11.5–13.5 Mn 1.0, Si 1.0 925–1010 °C, air or oil HRC 35–43 at 550–650 °C temper Valve parts, pump shafts, A268 TP410 tube
414 (S41400) 0.15 max 11.5–13.5 Ni 1.25–2.50, Mo 0.50 max 980–1010 °C, oil HRC 40–45 Higher-toughness shaft and fastener work
416 (S41600) 0.15 max 12.0–14.0 S 0.15 min, Mn 1.25 925–1010 °C HRC 30–40 Machined components, nuts, bushings
420 (S42000) 0.15 min, up to 0.40 12.0–14.0 Mn 1.0, Si 1.0 980–1010 °C, oil HRC 50–56 at 200–300 °C temper Cutlery, surgical instruments, plastic moulds
431 (S43100) 0.20 max 15.0–17.0 Ni 1.25–2.50 1010–1050 °C, oil HRC 40–48 Aircraft fittings, high-strength shafts
440A (S44002) 0.60–0.75 16.0–18.0 Mo 0.75 max 1010–1065 °C HRC 55–58 Cutlery, scalpels, valve trim
440B (S44003) 0.75–0.95 16.0–18.0 Mo 0.75 max 1010–1065 °C HRC 56–59 Bearings, wear plates, knives
440C (S44004) 0.95–1.20 16.0–18.0 Mo 0.75 max 1010–1065 °C HRC 58–62 Ball bearings, races, gauge parts

Hardening and Tempering: Choosing the Right Temper Window

Hardening begins with an austenitising soak above the critical temperature, followed by a quench fast enough to miss the pearlite and bainite noses. Thin sections of 410 can be air cooled; thicker sections and the higher-carbon grades need oil or, for some 440 work, interrupted or salt-bath quenching. The quench leaves a structure of martensite plus retained austenite, and the retained austenite fraction grows with carbon content, to the point where 440C may hold 10 % to 20 % after a normal quench.

Tempering then decides the final property set, and the choice is not free. Tempering in the range of roughly 425 °C to 600 °C produces tempered martensite embrittlement in these grades: impact toughness falls to a trough even though hardness is falling normally. Practical selections avoid that band. Below 300 °C the part keeps high hardness with low toughness, which is right for cutlery and bearings. Above 620 °C the part loses hardness but gains ductility and dimensional stability, which suits shafts and pressure parts. Double tempering, or a sub-zero treatment before tempering to transform retained austenite, is used where dimensional stability over time is critical.

For 440C, a common sequence is austenitise at 1010 °C to 1065 °C, quench, sub-zero at −70 °C or lower, then double temper at 150 °C to 200 °C for maximum hardness, or at 300 °C to 350 °C for better toughness at a small hardness cost. For 410 pressure tube and bar, austenitise at 925 °C to 1010 °C, quench, and temper at 550 °C to 650 °C to reach a tensile strength in the 700 to 850 MPa range with useful elongation.

Mechanical Property Behaviour

Three properties move together and must be traded deliberately. Hardness rises with carbon and with cooling rate; tensile strength tracks hardness closely at roughly 3.3 times the Vickers value in MPa; elongation and impact energy fall as hardness rises. A 410 in the annealed condition will show around 480 to 550 MPa tensile, 275 MPa yield and 20 % elongation or better, whereas the same grade hardened and tempered at 550 °C will reach 800 MPa tensile with elongation falling to about 12 % to 15 %.

The ductile-to-brittle transition is a real constraint for the higher-carbon grades and for thick sections. Charpy impact values should be specified by test temperature rather than by a single ambient figure whenever the part operates below about 0 °C. Section size also matters: hardenability of 410 is limited, so a heavy bar may not through-harden, and the core properties will be those of a partially transformed structure unless the grade is changed or the part is quenched more aggressively.

For tubular products the property set is governed by the tube standard rather than by the bar standard. ASTM A268 TP410 tube, for example, is normally supplied in the annealed condition with tensile and yield requirements suited to heat exchanger and condenser service where the tube must be rolled into a tubesheet without cracking, and hardening of that tube is not part of the delivery condition.

Welding: Why the Heat-Affected Zone Is the Weak Point

These steels can be welded in the annealed, hardened or hardened-and-tempered condition, but a hardened martensitic zone always forms adjacent to the fusion line because the weld thermal cycle re-austenitises and then rapidly cools a band of parent metal. The hardness of that band depends mainly on the carbon content of the parent metal. As hardness rises, toughness falls and the risk of hydrogen-assisted cracking rises with it.

Preheat and interpass control are the effective countermeasures. A preheat in the region of 200 °C to 315 °C, chosen from the carbon equivalent and the section thickness, slows the cooling rate through the martensite range and gives hydrogen time to escape. Interpass temperature must be held, not merely reached, because a rising interpass temperature on a multipass joint gradually converts a controlled operation into an uncontrolled one. Post-weld heat treatment follows: a temper at 650 °C to 750 °C for the 410 type brings the heat-affected zone back to a tempered condition and restores some toughness.

The 440 series is a different matter. These grades are rarely selected for welded construction, and filler metals of matching composition are not readily available in the market, so a joint in 440C is normally a braze, a mechanical fastening or a shrink fit rather than a fusion weld. Where a weld is unavoidable, the design should accept a softened or locally hardened zone that no practical heat treatment will fully correct.

Corrosion Behaviour in Real Service

The passive film on these grades is thin and chromium-dependent, so the practical limits are predictable. They perform adequately in atmospheric exposure, fresh water, mildly oxidising acids, steam and many organic media. They suffer in chloride environments, where pitting and crevice attack begin at much lower chloride levels than on 316L, and in reducing acids, where the film cannot repassivate. Hardening above about 40 HRC generally reduces corrosion resistance further, and the high-carbon 440 grades are notably less corrosion resistant than their chromium content suggests.

For oilfield and sour service the governing document is ISO 15156, which in North America is published as NACE MR0175. That standard restricts carbon and low-alloy steels to a maximum hardness, commonly 22 HRC, in sour environments, and treats martensitic stainless grades as a separate case requiring hardness control plus environmental limits on partial pressure of hydrogen sulphide, chloride concentration, pH and temperature. A buyer who intends to use a hardened martensitic part in wet sour gas must therefore check the specific grade and condition against ISO 15156-2 and the application limits rather than relying on the word stainless.

Surface condition also matters. A ground or polished surface on 410 resists pitting noticeably better than a rough turned surface because there are fewer crevices to hold chloride and fewer machining residues. Passivation to ASTM A967 after machining removes embedded iron and restores the chromium oxide film.

Where Martensitic Stainless Tube and Bar Are Specified

In tube form the main use is heat exchanger and condenser tube in mildly corrosive service at moderate temperature, supplied to ASTM A268 as TP410, where the combination of thermal conductivity, resistance to steam condensate and lower cost than austenitic tube is attractive. It also appears in mechanical tubing to ASTM A511 for hydraulic cylinders and shock absorber bodies where the bore is honed and the outer surface is machined.

In bar and forged form the range is wider: pump shafts, valve stems and trim, turbine blades, compressor parts, moulds and dies, surgical and dental instruments, cutlery blades, ball bearings and races, and fastener and structural fittings in 431. Each of these uses is decided by one property that the family delivers cheaply and that austenitic grades do not: the ability to hold a hard, wear-resistant, magnetic and dimensionally stable structure.

Inspection, Testing and Ordering Points

An inspection plan for a martensitic part usually combines chemical analysis, hardness survey, tension test, impact test where toughness governs, and a metallographic check for retained austenite, delta ferrite and decarburisation. Delta ferrite in 410 is a common defect of overheated austenitising; it forms on cooling when the composition sits near the ferrite boundary, and it lowers toughness and machinability. Decarburisation of the surface during hardening leaves a soft skin that will not hold the specified hardness, so hardness must be measured below the decarburised layer or the surface must be removed before testing.

The order should name the grade and its UNS number, the product standard with edition, the delivery condition and hardness range, the tempering temperature if the buyer needs a specific toughness level, the test temperature for impact, the acceptable non-metallic inclusion level if the part is highly stressed, and the surface finish and dimensional tolerances. For tubular goods, add the tube standard, the test pressure, and the corrosion test if the tube is going into a wet environment.

Because hardness and toughness are strongly process-dependent, a certificate that states only the grade and a tensile result is not enough for a hardened component. The heat treatment record, the tempering temperature actually used and the resulting hardness distribution across the section are the evidence that separates a controlled part from a part that merely met a room-temperature tensile requirement.

FAQ

Q: Are all martensitic stainless steels magnetic?
Yes. The body-centred tetragonal martensite and the ferrite that may accompany it are both ferromagnetic, so these grades respond to magnets in the annealed, hardened and tempered conditions. This is one practical way to separate them from the austenitic 300-series grades, which are essentially non-magnetic when fully annealed.

Q: Why is 410 preferred over 420 for tube and pressure parts?
Because carbon content drives weldability and toughness. Grade 410 with 0.15 % carbon maximum tolerates preheat, welding and post-weld tempering in a way that 420 with up to 0.40 % carbon does not. The 420 grade is chosen when hardness above 50 HRC is the governing requirement, and 410 when a pressure boundary and a weld must be produced reliably.

Q: What hardness can 440C reach and what is the cost?
A well-controlled 440C heat treatment reaches about 58 to 62 HRC after quenching from 1010 to 1065 °C, a sub-zero treatment and double tempering at 150 to 200 °C. The costs are low toughness, poor weldability, limited corrosion resistance and a real risk of cracking during quenching of complex shapes.

Q: Does tempering always reduce hardness?
Not monotonically in terms of toughness. Hardness falls as the tempering temperature rises, but impact toughness passes through a trough around 425 to 600 °C because of tempered martensite embrittlement. A part tempered in that band may be softer than one tempered at 300 °C yet still brittle, which is why the tempering temperature belongs in the specification.

Q: Can a martensitic stainless part be used in a chloride environment?
Only within clearly limited conditions. Resistance to pitting and crevice attack is far below that of 316L or the duplex grades, and it degrades further with increasing hardness and carbon content. Where chlorides are present plus wet conditions and stress, the specific grade and hardness must be checked against the environmental limits in ISO 15156 rather than accepted on the basis of the chromium content alone.

Q: What does delta ferrite in 410 indicate?
It indicates that the austenitising treatment was too hot, or the composition sits too close to the ferrite phase field, so ferrite formed during cooling and remained in the structure. Visible delta ferrite stringers reduce toughness and ductility, cause inconsistent machining and can act as initiation sites for corrosion, so a metallographic acceptance limit is often written into critical orders.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry